Skip to content
SPECIFICTION
Get listed

ADTool vs CAIRIS

ADTool

satoss.uni.lu

CAIRIS

cairis.org

Side by side

FigureADToolCAIRIS
Price from—Free
Free plan—Yes
Free trial——
Open source——
Web—Yes
Windows—Yes
macOS—Yes
Linux—Yes
API—Yes
Self-hosted—Yes
Plans published01
Spec score · Threat Modeling Software7.3 (#19)8.2 (#2)
DocumentationA standalone user manual is available for download for the previous stable version.It generates documentation including Volere compliant requirement specifications and GDPR DPIA documents.
PurposeADTool models and analyzes attack-defense scenarios represented as attack-defense trees and attack-defense terms.CAIRIS is an open source platform for eliciting, specifying, and validating secure and usable systems.

Plans

ADTool

No plans published.

ADTool pricing →

CAIRIS

  • FreeFree

CAIRIS pricing →

In their own words

ADTool

ADTool is free software for modeling and analyzing attack-defense scenarios. It uses attack-defense trees, attack-defense terms, and sequential attack trees, following a methodology developed through the ATREES, TREsPASS, and ADT2P projects. Users can create and edit trees, then perform quantitative bottom-up analysis. A modular display is intended for large real-life scenarios. The tool can rank possible attacks for selected attribute domains, supporting attack-path analysis and risk prioritization. Models can be saved, printed, exported to several formats, and given customized layouts. The maker lists a new beta release and an earlier stable release. The new version requires JDK 7 or later. The stable package is offered as a dependency-included jar of about 6.6 MB or a light package of about 1100 kB. A previous-version manual and source code for both versions are available. The project is associated with the University of Luxembourg’s Security and Trust of Software Systems group.

Visit satoss.uni.lu

CAIRIS

CAIRIS is an open-source platform for specifying and checking systems with security and usability requirements in view. It brings together design information such as assets, countermeasures, factoids, personas, requirements, and architectural components. As a design develops, it can generate 12 views covering perspectives such as people, risks, requirements, architecture, and physical location, as well as threat models including Data Flow Diagrams. Its security analysis uses attack and architectural patterns to assess attack surface and check for known security problems and potential GDPR compliance issues. CAIRIS can produce Volere-compliant requirement specifications and GDPR DPIA documents. Its API supports design apps and connections to existing toolchains. It is free under the Apache Software License. Deployment options include Docker, Vagrant, or source installation on supported platforms; Ubuntu is the most tested. The web app supports modern browsers other than Internet Explorer, including Edge. A Chrome extension can turn highlighted webpage text into references linked to a CAIRIS server. The live demo is rebuilt nightly, and its data is visible to everyone.

Visit cairis.org