Apache Hadoop HDFS vs Cloudera Data Lake Service
Apache Hadoop HDFS
hadoop.apache.orgCloudera Data Lake Service
cloudera.comSide by side
| Figure | Apache Hadoop HDFS | Cloudera Data Lake Service |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | — |
| Free plan | Yes | — |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | Yes | — |
| Web | — | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | — |
| Linux | Yes | — |
| API | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | — |
| Plans published | 2 | 1 |
| Spec score · Data Lake Software | 8.9 (#1) | 7.1 (#12) |
| Purpose | HDFS is a distributed file system designed for high-throughput access to large application data sets on commodity hardware. | Provides capabilities for data schema and metadata, metadata governance and management, data access authorization and authentication, and compliance-ready access auditing. |
| Security | Production clusters are expected to use Kerberos for caller authentication and access control. | Supports granular, dynamic, role- and attribute-based security policies, auditing of unauthorized access, and encryption at rest and in motion with key management. |
| Support | The project asks users not to request private support from its non-paid volunteers and directs help requests to module mailing lists. | Cloudera’s product page points users to product support, community, documentation, and downloads, and invites them to book a demo. |
Plans
Apache Hadoop HDFS
- Apache Hadoop HDFSFree
- Apache Hadoop / HDFS open-source distributionFree
Cloudera Data Lake Service
- Cloudera Data Lake ServicePriced on request
In their own words
Apache Hadoop HDFS
Apache Hadoop HDFS is a free, open-source distributed file system for high-throughput access to large application data sets on commodity hardware. It is designed for clusters of hundreds of nodes and can support tens of millions of files in one instance. HDFS copies file blocks across machines and detects failed DataNodes so it can start creating replacement copies. Its design prioritizes batch processing and streaming throughput rather than low-latency interactive workloads. Files follow a write-once, read-many model: appends and truncates are supported, but arbitrary in-place changes are not. Applications can connect through Java, a C wrapper, REST, a browser interface or an NFS gateway. The documentation lists connectors for Google Cloud Storage, Amazon S3, Azure Blob Storage and Azure Data Lake Storage. HDFS supports transparent encryption. Apache warns that without Kerberos caller authentication, anyone with network access to cluster servers can access data and run code, and recommends securing clusters before production. Apache also recommends checking release downloads with GPG signatures or SHA-512 checksums. The listed stable release is Hadoop 3.5.0, dated April 2, 2026.
Cloudera Data Lake Service
Cloudera Data Lake Service provides data governance, metadata management, access controls, and auditing for data lake workloads. It captures schema and metadata definitions that platform workloads discover or create, then supports search, lineage, chain-of-custody auditing, classification, profiling, and a business glossary. Security capabilities include role- and attribute-based policies, auditing of unauthorized access, and encryption at rest and in motion with key management. Apache Ranger can apply access policies at database, table, column, and file levels, including dynamic conditions such as time or geolocation. Apache Knox provides a protected single sign-on gateway to Data Lake and Cloudera Data Platform interfaces. A cluster includes Hive Metastore, Ranger, Atlas, and Knox. Cloudera supports light-duty and enterprise Data Lakes on AWS, Azure, and GCP. Listed capabilities also include SQL analytics, streaming ingestion, data sharing, and open table formats. The service has web and API access and supports hybrid deployment. The listed pricing note starts at $0.20, while the plan is also described as Contact Sales for pricing; cloud prices exclude infrastructure and networking costs.