AutoSec TARA Suite vs pytm

AutoSec TARA Suite is a pilot automotive threat-modelling and risk-management platform for analyst-led workflows aligned with ISO/SAE 21434 and UN R155 activities. Its analysis moves through item definition, asset and boundary identification, threat scenarios, attack analysis, impact assessment, and risk determination. Candidate threat scenarios are generated for analyst review and mapped to STRIDE categories. Risk assessment considers safety, financial, operational, and privacy impacts, then calculates attack potential to determine risk. Listed outputs include traceability matrices, PDF and Excel compliance bundles, and VSOC detection rule exports. Deployment options include analyst-led engagements, managed evaluation instances, and self-hosted customer instances. Controlled self-hosted evaluations and technical demonstrations are available on request. The suite is designed to support ISO/SAE 21434, UNECE R155, and ISO 26262 activities, but it does not certify products or organisations. Pricing is available on request.

pytm is a free, open-source Python framework for creating threat models from architectural descriptions. A model is defined in Python with elements such as servers, data stores, actors, processes, data flows, and trust boundaries. From it, pytm can generate data flow diagrams, sequence diagrams, and relevant threats. Templates can produce reports with diagrams and findings, and a RevealMD template can create slides for browser presentation. Data flow diagrams use Graphviz DOT, while sequence diagrams use PlantUML. Models can be imported from JSON with pytm's Python load function. Users can supply a custom threats file and change finding attributes such as CVSS score, response text, and severity. Requirements include Python 3.11 or later, Graphviz, Java OpenJDK 10 or 11, and plantuml.jar; Linux and macOS are listed, while Windows use is documented through Devbox in WSL. The project also documents container and Devbox dependency workflows. The README warns that strings in threats.json are evaluated with eval(), so the file's permissions need protection against unauthorized changes.