BaNaNaS vs ModWorkshop
BaNaNaS
bananas.openttd.orgModWorkshop
modworkshop.netSide by side
| Figure | BaNaNaS | ModWorkshop |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | Yes |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| API | — | Yes |
| Self-hosted | — | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Game Mod Repositories | 8.2 (#2) | 8.2 (#3) |
| Downloads | The site recommends using OpenTTD’s built-in content downloader to download content. | The site says downloads do not require an account. |
| Privacy | OpenTTD’s privacy statement says registration may collect a GitHub username and user identifier. | The privacy policy says users may browse anonymously and that the site does not sell, trade, or rent personal identification information. |
| Security | OpenTTD says it takes reasonable technical and organizational precautions to prevent loss, misuse, or alteration of personal information. | The privacy policy says the site adopts data collection, storage, processing, and security practices intended to protect information from unauthorized access, alteration, disclosure, or destruction. |
Plans
In their own words
BaNaNaS
BaNaNaS is a free content service for OpenTTD, offering downloadable game content through its website and the OpenTTD client. Its catalog covers base graphics, sounds and music, NewGRFs, AIs and AI libraries, game scripts and their libraries, scenarios, and heightmaps. Listings can show item names, latest versions, upload dates, licenses, and project sites when provided. The service gives access to the latest content files and retains older versions so save games that use them can be loaded. Users are directed to download content through OpenTTD’s built-in content downloader. Dependency tracking is available. BaNaNaS is described as a volunteer project. Uploading requires users to read the terms and sign in via GitHub; contributors must be authors of the material and use a license compatible with its source material. Uploaders grant the OpenTTD team rights to distribute the latest content centrally and through the website, and to retain older versions. OpenTTD says session cookies are used for authenticated areas such as BaNaNaS, and that it does not use functional or third-party cookies.
ModWorkshop
ModWorkshop is a free community platform for sharing and downloading game modifications, with listings for 65 games. Its catalog includes PAYDAY 2, PAYDAY: The Heist, Noita, and Crime Boss. Visitors can browse game pages, news, forums, Discord links, and community comments, while dependency tracking helps relate required components. Downloading does not require an account, and the site says it does not artificially throttle download speeds. The API is available to anyone and currently supports GET requests only. Open-source, community-maintained mod managers, update tools, and downloaders may integrate through it; official integration into games or developers’ first-party tools is forbidden. Uploaded submissions must be open source, with repository links or source code required for compiled or obfuscated code. ModWorkshop began as The Team Mystery in 2012 and adopted its current name in 2016. It runs on the web and offers an API.