Bibliometrix vs CADIMA

Bibliometrix is an open-source R tool for quantitative scientometric and bibliometric research. Its analyses include descriptive statistics, co-citation, co-authorship, keyword co-occurrence, thematic mapping, and historiographic networks. It works with bibliographic files from Web of Science, Scopus, Dimensions, The Lens, PubMed, and the Cochrane Library; companion R packages add API support for Dimensions, NCBI PubMed, and Scopus. Biblioshiny provides a web interface for people without coding or R knowledge, while the package can also work with other statistical R packages. Biblioverse packages extend the system from data collection to text and content analysis. The openalexR package can bring publication, author, institution, and concept metadata from OpenAlex into bibliometrix structures. Using bibliometrix or biblioshiny requires R. Stable releases are distributed through CRAN, while a daily-updated GitHub beta may contain minor bugs. PubMed exports lack citation and reference-list metadata, preventing citation, bibliographic coupling, and co-citation links. Web of Science and Scopus service access requires a subscription.

CADIMA is a free web application for planning, conducting, and documenting systematic reviews, systematic maps, and other literature reviews. It accepts review questions from any research discipline and lets review teams work together worldwide, with no stated limit on reviewers at different stages. During screening, records can be allocated automatically while allowing independent and parallel assessment. CADIMA removes duplicate records automatically and supports bulk PDF uploads. It records the review process in detail, while its evidence synthesis database provides guidance and hosts synthesis data. The site describes planned archiving for review and evidence-map data and modules. Access data are used for statistical purposes and are not passed to third parties, according to the privacy policy. A scientist-and-programmer team handles questions, and user feedback informs further development. CADIMA is published by the Julius Kühn-Institut in Quedlinburg, Germany. The footer identifies version 2.2.4.2, dated April 2023.