Black Duck Polaris vs HCL AppScan

Black Duck Polaris is a cloud application-security platform that brings several types of testing into software development workflows. Its engines cover static analysis through Polaris fAST Static, software composition analysis through Polaris fAST SCA, and dynamic analysis through Polaris fAST Dynamic. It also scans infrastructure as code and detects secrets. Dashboards, correlated and enriched findings, portfolio analytics, and role-based views help teams organize risk. Polaris can produce software bills of materials using package-manager, signature, binary, and container analysis. It generates compliance reports for PCI DSS, HIPAA, GDPR, SOC 2, and ISO 27001, and maps findings to OWASP Top 10 and CWE. Repository integrations include Azure DevOps, Bitbucket, GitHub, and GitLab. Issue tracking connects with Azure DevOps, Jira Cloud and Data Center, and ServiceNow; Jira and ServiceNow support two-way synchronization. Pricing is on request, and a free trial is available. The service description limits an application to 1 million lines of code and five supporting projects.

HCL AppScan identifies and prioritizes software vulnerabilities and helps teams remediate them across the development lifecycle. It combines static, dynamic, interactive and open-source composition analysis for source code, running applications, APIs and dependencies. API security testing supports OpenAPI/Swagger, Postman and GraphQL, and can uncover shadow, zombie and undocumented APIs. HCL says its AI-powered analysis reduces false positives and helps prioritize critical risks. Deployment options include cloud and on-premises; Enterprise also lists private cloud. Integrations include CI systems, code repositories, issue-management services and developer tools such as Android Studio. CodeSweep is a free on-prem GitHub extension for pull-request SAST scanning, with support for more than 35 languages. AppScan Standard is designed for security experts and penetration testers assessing web applications and APIs, and supports specified 64-bit Windows versions. The 14-day trial allows five scans in total, one at a time, with a four-hour limit per scan. Its summary reports omit issue details and remediation tasks; private-site scanning, regulatory reports and IAST are also excluded.