Box86 vs cnc-ddraw
Box86
github.comcnc-ddraw
github.comSide by side
| Figure | Box86 | cnc-ddraw |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | Yes |
| Windows | — | Yes |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| Android | — | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Game Compatibility Layers | 7.9 (#7) | 9.0 (#1) |
| License | The project repository identifies the software as MIT licensed. | The repository is released under the MIT License, permitting use, modification, distribution and sublicensing with the notice retained. |
| Purpose | Box86 runs x86 Linux programs, including games, on non-x86 Linux systems such as ARM. | cnc-ddraw reimplements the DirectDraw API to improve compatibility in older 2D games that have issues such as black screens, poor performance, crashes, or defective Alt+Tab behavior. |
Plans
In their own words
Box86
Box86 runs 32-bit x86 Linux programs on Linux systems using other processor architectures, including ARM. It translates programs at runtime and connects them to native system libraries such as libc, libm, SDL, and OpenGL. The host must provide a 32-bit little-endian system or a 32-bit userspace subsystem; Box86 does not translate 32-bit programs for a 64-bit-only userspace. On ARM, its dynamic recompiler is described as providing a 5 to 10 times speed boost over the interpreter. The project names WorldOfGoo, Airline Tycoon Deluxe, FTL, and several GameMaker Linux games as examples that run, and links to a GitHub issue list for compatibility information. Wine is supported, though many games require graphics drivers. Steam can run with Box86 but also needs Box64 to be fully usable and uses substantial memory. Vulkan wrapping requires a 32-bit Vulkan driver; the Pi 4 Vulkan driver does not support DXVK. Box86 is the legacy 32-bit version of Box64 and is free under the MIT license, which provides the software as-is and disclaims warranties and liability.
cnc-ddraw
cnc-ddraw reimplements DirectDraw to address compatibility problems in older 2D games, including black screens, poor performance, crashes, and faulty Alt+Tab behavior. It can use GDI, OpenGL, or Direct3D 9 rendering, selecting a renderer automatically. Display options include windowed, fullscreen exclusive, and borderless modes; Alt+Enter switches between fullscreen and windowed. GLSL shaders provide upscaling, and other options include an FPS limiter, VSync, mouse sensitivity scaling, and saving and restoring window position, size, and state. The project lists Windows, Linux through Wine, macOS, Android, and virtual machines as supported environments. Setup involves extracting cnc-ddraw.zip into the game folder and starting the game. Wine users must configure the ddraw override in winecfg or run cnc-ddraw config.exe once. The game must use a DirectDraw Software renderer; Direct3D games are not supported. cnc-ddraw is free under the MIT License.