cfn-nag vs Sonobuoy

cfn-nag is free, MIT-licensed software that scans AWS CloudFormation templates for patterns that may indicate insecure infrastructure. It checks for overly permissive IAM policies and security-group rules, disabled access logging or encryption, and password literals. The scanner accepts JSON, .template, YAML, and YML files, and recursively processes subdirectories when given a directory. Results print to standard output, with JSON output available; failures return a non-zero exit code while warnings return success. Installation is documented through RubyGems and Homebrew, with Ruby 2.5 or later required for gem installation. A Dockerfile and Docker Hub image are provided. cfn-nag can run in GitHub Actions and AWS CodePipeline. Profiles, deny lists, per-resource suppressions, and custom rules support policy tailoring. Static analysis needs supplied parameter values to assess them and does not inspect false Fn::If outcomes by default.

Sonobuoy is a free, open-source diagnostic tool for examining Kubernetes cluster state with non-destructive configuration tests. It can check a cluster against official Kubernetes specifications and produce diagnostics for troublesome workloads. Teams can build plugins for additional tests and data collection. Its default plugins run Kubernetes end-to-end tests and gather systemd logs; community options include CIS Benchmarks, Kube-hunter, Who-can, Cluster-Inventory, and Reliability Scanner. It is cluster agnostic and officially supports the latest three minor Kubernetes versions. Beginning with version 0.20, it supports Kubernetes 1.17 or later. Sonobuoy can run end-to-end tests with custom registries in air-gapped deployments. It requires an active Kubernetes cluster and an admin kubeconfig, and can be installed from binary releases or through Homebrew on macOS. The project provides community support through GitHub. Its documentation warns that default settings need explicit hardening, and notes that some logging and retrieval commands can fail on Docker Desktop Kubernetes.