Clusternet vs Kamaji

Clusternet is a free, open-source add-on for managing Kubernetes clusters across public and private cloud, hybrid, on-premises, and edge environments. It lets operators manage member clusters from a parent cluster and access them as though they were local. It deploys Kubernetes resources, custom resource definitions, and Helm charts, with configuration tailored to individual clusters. Application scheduling can replicate workloads or distribute them by cluster weight or available capacity. Clusternet supports clusters from AWS, Google Cloud, Tencent Cloud, and Alibaba Cloud, along with on-premises systems, k3s, and edge clusters. It can discover and register clusters created by Cluster API and configure network tunnels for clusters in VPC networks, at the edge, or behind a firewall. Dynamic RBAC rules control access to managed clusters, and Submariner integration can connect workloads across clusters. Installation options include Helm and manual setup. A kubectl plugin is available through Krew or as a binary. Linux builds are listed for several architectures. Clusternet is a CNCF Sandbox project.

Kamaji runs Kubernetes control planes as pods inside a management cluster, giving platform teams a way to operate multiple tenant clusters. Each tenant control plane is independent and separated from others. It uses upstream Kubernetes components and kubeadm, with CNCF-conformant tenant clusters. Worker nodes may run on bare metal, virtual machines, or cloud instances across cloud, data-center, edge, and bare-metal environments. Kamaji integrates with Cluster API for infrastructure provisioning and lifecycle management, and supports cluster provisioning, multi-cluster management, policy enforcement, and upgrade management. Datastores include etcd and MySQL- or PostgreSQL-compatible databases through kine; NATS support is experimental. Konnectivity, enabled by default, creates secure tunnels to worker nodes. Prometheus-format metrics cover management and tenant planes. Metrics endpoints use unauthenticated plaintext by default, with documented HTTPS and bearer-token options. Kamaji is free under Apache 2.0; Clastix also sells enterprise support.