Cobbler vs xCAT
Cobbler
cobbler.github.ioxCAT
xcat.orgSide by side
| Figure | Cobbler | xCAT |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| API | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Bare Metal Provisioning Software | 8.1 (#7) | 7.3 (#23) |
| Spec score · Bare Metal as a Service (BMaaS) Software | 8.2 (#3) | 7.3 (#10) |
| Spec score · OS Deployment Software | 8.0 (#8) | 7.3 (#20) |
| Spec score · OS Imaging & Deployment Software | 8.0 (#7) | 7.3 (#16) |
| Spec score · IT Automation Software | 8.0 (#26) | 7.3 (#52) |
| Spec score · Data Center Automation | 8.0 (#8) | 7.3 (#16) |
| Integrations | Cobbler can integrate with external configuration management systems including cfengine3, Puppet, bcfg2 and Chef, and also has an internal lightweight system. | The documentation lists OpenStack and SoftLayer cloud integration and mentions configuring HPC applications including GPFS, Parallel Environment, and LSF. |
| Provisioning | It supports PXE deployments, virtualization with Xen, QEMU/KVM or VMware, and reinstallation of existing Linux systems. | xCAT provisions operating systems on physical or virtual machines using diskful, stateless, or cloned installation methods. |
| Purpose | Cobbler is a Linux installation server for setting up and automating network installation environments. | xCAT automates deployment, scaling, and management of bare metal servers and virtual machines. |
| Security | The security policy says Cobbler has no SELinux or AppArmor profile and advises protecting it because it manages DHCP and TFTP and has broad network control. | The security documentation covers TLS configuration, transmission channels, command access control, auditing, password management, secure zones, and IP-based access control. |
| Support | The project directs users to its mailing list, GitHub issues and community chat for help. | The project encourages GitHub issues for support and also lists an older user email list. |
Plans
In their own words
Cobbler
Cobbler is free, self-hosted Linux server software for creating and automating network installation environments. It supports PXE deployments, virtualization with Xen, QEMU/KVM, or VMware, and reinstallation of existing Linux systems. Administrators can coordinate DNS, DHCP, package updates, power management, and configuration-management orchestration. Interfaces include a command line, WebUI, and Python and XML-RPC APIs. Automated installation formats include AutoYaST for SUSE and openSUSE, Kickstart, and Preseed for Debian and Ubuntu. Templates and reusable snippets generate installation files and manage services such as DNS and DHCP. Cobbler integrates with cfengine3, Puppet, bcfg2, and Chef, or its internal lightweight system. It can be installed from distribution packages or source; pip installation is documented but not recommended. Python 3 is required, and server setup needs Apache, certificate, and administration knowledge. Security guidance notes broad network control and no SELinux or AppArmor profile. The project describes use in small and large installations.