CodART vs Comby

CodART is a toolkit for automated refactoring and multi-objective optimization of Java source code. It documents 47 refactoring operations, including Extract Class, Move Method, and Encapsulate Field, and supports project-level and batch work. Its optimization uses NSGA-II and NSGA-III across eight QMOOD quality metrics. The toolkit also includes PPO-based generation of refactoring sequences and models that predict testability from source code metrics. PMD integration with custom rulesets supports code smell detection, while SciTools Understand handles code parsing and metric computation. The documented interfaces are a React web interface and a FastAPI REST API, and Docker Compose instructions explain how to run the services locally. CodART is free under an MIT License, which permits use, copying, modification, distribution, sublicensing, and sale subject to its conditions. The setup requires a separate SciTools Understand professional license; academic licenses are available for research purposes. The quick-start calls for at least 8 GB RAM and 4 CPU cores, with 12 GB or more recommended for large projects. Java is its listed supported language.

Comby is a free, open-source tool for searching and changing code structure with lightweight templates. It recognizes basic syntax in code, strings, and comments across many languages, with parsers listed for C/C++, C#, Go, Java, JavaScript, Python, Rust, Swift, and TypeScript, plus a generic matcher for other formats. The project targets large refactors and one-off changes, and an interactive review mode lets users inspect proposed edits. Comby can run from its command line, Python bindings, or HTTP requests sent to a server on your machine. Installation instructions cover macOS with Homebrew, Ubuntu, Windows through Ubuntu on WSL, and Docker; building from source is also described. Linked projects include an Emacs package and a prototype VS Code extension. Other uses include structural code search, compiler fuzzing, test-case reduction, editor find and replace, and academic research. Comby matches balanced delimiters while accounting for comments and string literals, and supports regex search. It is self-hosted and available for API, Linux, macOS, and Windows use. The Apache-2.0 license is identified in the public repository.