Comment Picker vs PromoSimple
Comment Picker
commentpicker.comPromoSimple
promosimple.comSide by side
| Figure | Comment Picker | PromoSimple |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | $7.99/mo | $14/mo |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 4 | 7 |
| Spec score · Social Media Contest Software | 9.2 (#1) | 7.9 (#14) |
| Spec score · Sweepstakes Software | 9.1 (#1) | 7.9 (#7) |
| Data handling | The maker says it does not store participant names or other personal data on its server, while giveaway results may be stored when users save or share them and Premium results are saved to the account. | The entrant FAQ says submitted entry data is securely stored, accessible to the giveaway administrator, and not used or sold by PromoSimple as personally identifiable data. |
| Founded | Comment Picker says it started in 2015, with the domain registered on May 27 that year. | 2011 |
| Support | The maker offers contact through social media, says it does not offer phone support, and aims to reply within one day with a maximum response time of three days. | The pricing page directs questions to [email protected] and says the team will get back to users as soon as possible. |
| Winner selection | The tools support random-comment selection, and selected platforms also offer first-comment, last-comment, most-liked-comment, and most-comments methods. | The service offers random and manual winner selections. |
Plans
Comment Picker
- FreeFree
- Premium$9.99 a month
- Premium monthly$9.99 a month
- Premium annual$95.91 a year
PromoSimple
- FreeFree
- Basic$14 a month
- Businesses$29 a month
- Premium$59 a month
- Basic (annual)$171 a year
- Businesses (annual)$351 a year
- Premium (annual)$711 a year
In their own words
Comment Picker
Comment Picker is a web service with more than 100 tools for giveaways, contests, social media tasks, and exports. Its giveaway tools draw winners from comments on social posts and videos, with listed support for Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, X, Reddit, Threads, and Bluesky. Organizers can remove duplicate participants, require mentions, filter by text, date, or like count, and exclude users or past winners. Depending on the platform, winner selection can be random or use first comment, last comment, most-liked comment, or most comments. Results can carry customized branding and be shared as a public page, certificate image, announcement video, or screen recording. The service also includes entry forms, exports, and moderation tools. The free plan includes over 100 tools, but individual limits vary; examples allow up to 100 comments for Instagram, Facebook, or YouTube giveaways. Premium costs $9.99 per month, or $95.91 per year, and includes unlimited comments for those three platforms, up to 10 winners, unlimited monthly exports, and entry forms with up to 50,000 entries. Founded in 2015 by Koen Knol, the service is based in Nieuwveen, The Netherlands.
PromoSimple
PromoSimple is a web-based service for building and running giveaways, sweepstakes, contests, and other promotional campaigns. Its workflow covers designing a campaign, setting its launch dates, promoting it, and choosing a winner. Entry forms can collect social actions and custom details, or include polls, surveys, and quizzes. Available entry methods include email or Facebook login, actions on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest, referral links, and custom fields. Forms can be embedded on websites, blogs, and Facebook pages, while campaigns can also reach the Giveaways Network. PromoSimple offers random or manual winner selection, real-time reports, and CSV exports. Its pricing page lists email integrations with MailChimp, Campaign Monitor, MadMimi, and Constant Contact. The free plan allows 50 entrants and has a seven-day limit. Paid plans start at $14/mo (annual); Basic is listed at $171 a year, Businesses at $351 a year, and Premium at $711 a year. The service also describes encrypted SSL, data handling, and cancellation terms; paid plans can be canceled immediately from the Account page, with features remaining through the paid period.