Comtech FX Series WAN Optimization vs OpenNOP
Comtech FX Series WAN Optimization
comtech.comOpenNOP
opennop.orgSide by side
| Figure | Comtech FX Series WAN Optimization | OpenNOP |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | — | Free |
| Free plan | — | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · WAN Optimization Software | 7.4 (#12) | 7.7 (#10) |
| Purpose | The FX Series optimizes, compresses, bonds, balances, and prioritizes high IP traffic to improve broadband quality of experience. | OpenNOP is an open-source Linux network accelerator designed to optimize traffic over point-to-point, partially meshed, and full-meshed IP networks. |
Plans
Comtech FX Series WAN Optimization
- FX Series WAN OptimizationPriced on request
In their own words
Comtech FX Series WAN Optimization
Comtech FX Series WAN Optimization is a self-hosted appliance solution for optimizing high IP traffic, especially satellite links across GEO, MEO, and LEO. It can compress, bond, balance, prioritize, and shape traffic, with a Protocol Enhancement Proxy at both ends. Turbostreaming accelerates file transfers and web browsing; the datasheet states over 150 Mbps per user TCP session and up to 600 Mbps file transfer across 500 ms GEO links. The system supports transparent Layer 2 and Layer 3 operation, VLAN and MPLS stacks, and L2/L3 VPNs with overlapping IP spaces. It accelerates 4G/LTE and 5G traffic in GTP tunnels and supports IPv4 and IPv6 together. QoS can classify traffic by VPN, address, protocol, port, or label. Optional features include header, payload, GZIP, and packet compression, plus byte caching. FX5020e can bond satellite segments. License tiers limit accelerated TCP sessions; excess sessions pass through unaccelerated.
OpenNOP
OpenNOP is a free, GPLv3 open-source Linux network accelerator for point-to-point, partially meshed, and full-meshed IP networks. Its stated aim is improving performance on low-speed links such as ISDN, DSL, DS1, frame-relay, and VPN circuits. Implemented functionality includes LZ compression of TCP segment payloads and peer discovery through custom TCP options added to IP packets. A heartbeat between the user-space daemon and kernel module lets the module switch to bypass mode. The manual describes inline deployment and out-of-line deployment with policy-based routing. A prebuilt appliance image is identified as the easiest installation option. Custom Linux hosts require libnfnetlink, libnetfilter_queue, and libnl, and the manual says any Linux distribution should work. The project is self-hosted, with hybrid deployment listed, and system administrators are its intended audience using a command-line interface. Features marked todo include block-based data reduction, a WCCPv2 client, CLI configuration and statistics, and a web interface. SourceForge labels the project Alpha and lists its last update as 2015-12-28.