D3 SOAR vs Shuffle

D3 Smart SOAR automates security operations workflows and incident response as SaaS hosted by D3 or on-premises software. Its Event Pipeline normalizes, deduplicates, triages, and enriches alerts; D3 claims this can reduce events requiring human attention by up to 99%. A codeless playbook editor, ready-made library, and reusable automation blocks support response workflows. Smart SOAR integrates with hundreds of tools across SIEM, EDR, NDR, TIP, and ITSM categories. D3 says it will build missing integrations free of charge. Threat-intelligence reputation results enrich incidents and contribute to an overall risk score. Existing playbooks and integrations cover phishing, ransomware, and password resets. Full multi-tenancy supports managed security service providers and managed detection and response firms. The platform includes event triggers, scheduled runs, approval steps, incident integrations, and audit logs. D3’s customer-success program describes implementation planning, training, integration optimization, technical documentation, and Customer Success Manager support. Pricing is on request, with a demo request offered.

Shuffle is an open-source automation platform for security teams to build and run workflows. Its visual designer works with a no-code app creator that can generate integrations from Swagger or OpenAPI specifications and API documentation URLs. The public catalog contains more than 2,500 apps, including Slack, Gmail, MISP, Wazuh, Splunk, and Jira. Workflows can start through webhooks, schedules, subflows, or user input; extension triggers include AWS Lambda, AWS S3, Kafka, and Pub/Sub.

Deployment choices include self-hosted open source, self-hosted licensed software, Shuffle Cloud, and hybrid setups. Documented runtime architectures include Docker Compose, Docker Swarm, a cloud-hybrid local Orborus runner, and Kubernetes with Helm charts. Shuffle documents bcrypt password hashing, AES-256 encryption, tenant-controlled SAML/SSO and MFA, and a Bearer-token API. The free Scale plan is free and includes 2,000 app runs per month, with a hard limit, three tenants, and one location. Custom Python apps are not yet easy to create for Shuffle Cloud, though on-premises instances support local app hotloading.