DisplayBuddy vs ExtLume

DisplayBuddy controls supported external monitor settings from a Mac menu bar or Windows taskbar. Depending on the display, it can adjust brightness, contrast, speaker volume, input source, resolution, and rotation. The Mac app uses DDC for hardware control and can use gamma dimming when a monitor does not respond. The maker says it also controls supported LG webOS and Samsung Tizen smart monitors over Wi-Fi. Users can save presets and synchronize brightness across displays. On Mac, presets can be scheduled by sunrise, sunset, time of day, charger state, or connected display; the app also supports Shortcuts, Siri, a command-line interface, and MCP. The Windows app supports Windows 10 and 11, with presets, hotkeys, input switching, and resolution and refresh-rate controls. Personal costs $24.99, paid once for one Mac, Pro costs $29.99, paid once for up to two Macs, and Family costs $49.99, paid once for up to five Macs; each includes lifetime access. There is no free plan, but a 7-day trial is available. Core controls work offline after internet-based license activation.

ExtLume is a Windows tray app for adjusting external-monitor brightness when Windows provides a brightness control only for the laptop panel. It offers a separate slider for each safely identified active external display and shows its EDID model name. When the monitor and the full cable or dock chain support DDC/CI, the app changes the physical backlight. If that is unavailable, it can use a click-through dimming overlay on a safely isolated external desktop area; this changes the image but not backlight power. ExtLume handles multiple displays, mirrored groups, hot-plugging, and resume, while excluding built-in panels and virtual displays. It targets Windows 10 and Windows 11 and requires .NET Framework 4.8. The free, MIT-licensed public beta is available from GitHub Releases as a per-user installer or portable ZIP and requires no administrator rights. ExtLume says it works offline without telemetry or network requests. It stores limited local monitor and dimming data, and its controls are limited to brightness rather than arbitrary VCP commands, resets, or automatic display substitution.