Dogtag Certificate System vs KeyTalk CKMS
Dogtag Certificate System
dogtagpki.org
KeyTalk CKMS
keytalk.comSide by side
| Figure | Dogtag Certificate System | KeyTalk CKMS |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | €5/mo |
| Free plan | Yes | — |
| Free trial | — | Yes |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | — | Yes |
| Windows | — | Yes |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| iOS | — | Yes |
| Android | — | Yes |
| API | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 12 |
| Spec score · Certificate Management Software | 7.9 (#12) | 8.9 (#3) |
| Spec score · Public Key Infrastructure Software | 7.9 (#11) | 8.8 (#2) |
| Certificate lifecycle | It supports certificate issuance, revocation, retrieval, certificate revocation list generation and publishing, and certificate profiles. | CKMS provides a central repository for certificates and keys, automated or semi-automated deployment and renewal, and reporting, notifications, and alerts. |
| Deployment | The project README gives Fedora installation commands and points to deployment instructions for subsystems, clones, and HSMs. | CKMS is delivered as a virtual machine for customer infrastructure, private cloud environments including AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud, or KeyTalk-managed PKI as a service. |
Plans
KeyTalk CKMS
- S/MIME on-premise€5 a month
- S/MIME hosted SaaS€6.50 a month
- CKMS 0–49 seatsPrice not published
- CKMS 100,000+ seatsPriced on request
- CKMS 10,000–24,999 seatsPrice not published
- CKMS 1,000–2,499 seatsPrice not published
- CKMS 25,000–49,999 seatsPrice not published
- CKMS 2,500–9,999 seatsPrice not published
- CKMS 250–999 seatsPrice not published
- CKMS 50,000–74,999 seatsPrice not published
In their own words
Dogtag Certificate System
Dogtag Certificate System has no write-up on Specifiction yet; its figures are above.
KeyTalk CKMS
KeyTalk CKMS automates PKI implementation and the enrollment, distribution and management of digital certificates. It keeps certificates and keys in a central repository and supports automated or semi-automated deployment and renewal, alongside reporting, notifications and alerts. Smart Security Scan finds certificates and keys on a network so valid findings can be imported. The product includes a private certificate authority that can operate beneath an existing root or as a standalone root. Integrations and protocols include DigiCert, DigiCert QuoVadis, GlobalSign, Microsoft CA, Intune, MobileIron, load balancers, HSMs, Citrix, SCEP and ACME. Access controls include AD and Entra ID authorization, multifactor authentication and role-based controls. CKMS can run as a virtual machine on customer infrastructure, in private cloud environments such as AWS, Azure and Google Cloud, or as KeyTalk-managed PKI service. General CKMS pricing is on request, and a free trial is available. Separate S/MIME plans cost €5 a month for on-premise service and €6.50 a month for hosted SaaS, billed per user per month.