DPlaneOS vs napp-it

DPlaneOS is a ZFS-first storage operating system for homelab and small-office NAS deployments. It manages pools, datasets, snapshots, replication, encryption, quotas, S.M.A.R.T. and POSIX ACLs, with sharing through SMB, NFS, iSCSI and NVMe-oF. It can manage Docker and Compose stacks, ZFS-clone sandboxes, atomic updates with rollback, and an in-browser terminal. Its architecture combines a Go daemon, PostgreSQL state, a React interface and a NixOS appliance. Identity options include local users, LDAP or Active Directory, OIDC SSO, TOTP 2FA and API tokens. Cloud synchronization supports S3, Backblaze B2, Google Drive, Azure, Dropbox and rclone-compatible targets. Prometheus/OpenMetrics exposes storage and system metrics. Optional high availability is off by default; several HA configurations and NVMe-oF over TCP are marked experimental. Installation supports x86_64 and aarch64, including Raspberry Pi 5, with offline ISOs. The free Community Edition is licensed under AGPLv3. Minimum hardware is a 64-bit CPU and 8 GB RAM; 16 GB is recommended. One person maintains the project, which offers no vendor support.

napp-it is a client-server web GUI for managing storage on one machine or across server fleets. It supports in-house storage servers and clusters, S3 cloud servers, and AI providers. Its central interface runs on FreeBSD, Illumos, Linux, macOS, Solaris, and Windows, and can manage servers without an agent or extra virtual machine. Sharing protocols include SMB, NFS, S3, iSCSI, and Fibre Channel. ZFS capabilities include AES-256-GCM encryption, end-to-end checksums, snapshots, automatic healing, and optional real-time deduplication. Replication is incremental, can link arbitrary servers, and can be encrypted during transfer. The S3-compatible endpoint works with Nextcloud, rclone, backup tools, and MinIO clients. Monitoring covers performance, disk health through S.M.A.R.T., JBOD enclosure maps, and network virtualization. CS Home is free for noncommercial home use, allows up to three servers, and includes no support. SE Free allows commercial and home use but excludes individual support and Pro features. A new installation includes a 30-day evaluation of Pro features.