Dune II - The Maker Map Editor vs NetRadiant

Dune II – The Maker Map Editor is an in-game tool for creating and editing skirmish maps in the open-source Dune II remake. Players can build maps without leaving the game and then play them immediately. Editing tools include terrain painting, spice placement, player starting positions, zoom, pan and symmetry. Grid and axis overlays help with placement, while undo, redo, copy and paste support revisions. Edited maps are saved in the skirmish folder and appear in the skirmish map selection screen. The editor is described as an initial version focused on essential playable skirmish maps, with plans to expand it for campaign maps. Version 0.8.5 also includes minimap move orders, camera tracking for selected units, configurable key bindings, improved pathfinding and a random-game option for skirmishes. It is free and open source, with Linux, macOS and Windows listed. The release page offers a stable download as d2tm.zip and source code. Feedback and issue reports can go through Discord, forums or GitHub tickets.

NetRadiant is a free, open-source 3D game level editor that uses brushes to build levels. It has first-class compatibility with Xonotic and Unvanquished and supports about 30 other games, with support varying by game. The project is driven by Xonotic, receives support from Unvanquished, and is maintained by a community of gamers, mappers, modders and game developers. It originated as a fork of Id Software’s GtkRadiant project. Listed downloads include Linux 64-bit, Windows 32-bit and 64-bit, macOS 64-bit and FreeBSD 64-bit builds. The builds include daemonmap for Unvanquished navmesh generation and q3map2 patches for Smokin’ Guns. Released Xonotic files work without an extra mapping support package. Linux use requires a working GTK2 and OpenGL environment. Windows builds offer optional Mesa3D rendering, described as a workaround for some older Intel chips on Windows 10. A 2022 project post described macOS support as new and potentially rough, including possible multi-screen configuration problems. The download page lists version 1.5.0-20220628.