Dune II - The Maker Map Editor vs Tiled
Dune II - The Maker Map Editor
dune2themaker.fundynamic.comTiled
mapeditor.orgSide by side
| Figure | Dune II - The Maker Map Editor | Tiled |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | Yes | — |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 2 | 1 |
| Spec score · Game Level Editors | 8.7 (#1) | 7.4 (#18) |
| Desktop platforms | The project publishes binaries and build instructions for Windows, Linux and macOS. | The downloadable tool is listed for Windows, macOS, and Linux. |
| Integrations | The maker’s GitHub README says the game uses FluidSynth for MIDI music and requires a General MIDI soundfont for audio playback. | The documentation lists libraries and game frameworks that can read or render TMX and JSON maps. |
| Support | The maker directs users to Discord, the forums, or GitHub tickets for feedback and issues. | Tiled development supporters receive regular development updates, a special Discord role, and priority support. |
| What it does | Dune II – The Maker is an open-source remake of Westwood’s Dune 2 that preserves the original style while adding modern controls, graphics and quality-of-life improvements. | Tiled is a 2D level editor for developing game content, primarily tile maps, with support for free image placement and annotations. |
Plans
Dune II - The Maker Map Editor
- Dune II - The MakerFree
- Dune II – The MakerFree
In their own words
Dune II - The Maker Map Editor
Dune II – The Maker Map Editor is an in-game tool for creating and editing skirmish maps in the open-source Dune II remake. Players can build maps without leaving the game and then play them immediately. Editing tools include terrain painting, spice placement, player starting positions, zoom, pan and symmetry. Grid and axis overlays help with placement, while undo, redo, copy and paste support revisions. Edited maps are saved in the skirmish folder and appear in the skirmish map selection screen. The editor is described as an initial version focused on essential playable skirmish maps, with plans to expand it for campaign maps. Version 0.8.5 also includes minimap move orders, camera tracking for selected units, configurable key bindings, improved pathfinding and a random-game option for skirmishes. It is free and open source, with Linux, macOS and Windows listed. The release page offers a stable download as d2tm.zip and source code. Feedback and issue reports can go through Discord, forums or GitHub tickets.
Tiled
Tiled is a free 2D level editor for game content, especially tile maps, with support for free image placement and annotations. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux. Map layers support rectangular, isometric, staggered isometric, staggered hexagonal and oblique projections. Tile-layer tools include a stamp brush, line and circle drawing, selection, automatic terrain transitions and pattern matching. Object layers can hold rectangles, points, ellipses, polygons, polylines and tile objects that can be scaled or rotated. The editor also includes tile animation and collision editing. Its TMX map format supports multiple tilesets per map, and the documentation lists libraries and game frameworks that can read or render TMX and JSON maps. Plugins can add map or tileset formats, and JavaScript can extend the editor. The maker describes Tiled as free software that users may use, modify and redistribute under the same terms. Listed 64-bit downloads require Windows 10, macOS 13 or Ubuntu 22.04 or an equivalent distribution. The manual says much of it still needs to be written.