Elastic Security vs Vigil

Elastic Security combines SIEM, XDR, endpoint security, and cloud security for detecting, preventing, and responding to cyber threats. Detection options include prebuilt and customizable rules, machine-learning anomaly detection, and threat hunting. Elastic Defend uses machine learning, behavioral analysis, and prebuilt rules to address endpoint threats; cloud capabilities cover cloud and Kubernetes security posture management, workload protection, and vulnerability management. Elastic Workflows can automate triage, enrichment, response, notifications, and case management. Elastic lists more than 400 prebuilt integrations and up to 1,000 total security and data-source integrations, alongside native OpenTelemetry support. The software can run on Elastic Cloud or self-managed infrastructure, with APIs and query options KQL, Lucene, and ES|QL. The free Basic plan includes SIEM, XDR, and host security analysis. Elastic Cloud Hosted and Serverless offer a 14-day free trial. Security Analytics Essentials is listed at $0.09 a month, with retention priced separately; Essentials also includes endpoint protection, while retention is priced separately at as low as $0.017 per retained GB per month. Elastic Cloud uses HTTPS for internet-facing and inter-node communications and encrypts cluster data at rest.

Vigil is a self-hosted SIEM that collects endpoint events, evaluates Sigma detections in real time, and returns structured JSON for AI agents. It runs on Linux, macOS, and Windows, or as a self-hosted service, without requiring a cloud account. Its single binary collects Windows Event Logs or Linux journald and sends batches every five seconds; short-lived enrollment tokens support secure agent onboarding. Vigil includes 41 Sigma rules covering 10 MITRE ATT&CK tactics. Its HQL query language searches event history with aggregations, timelines, endpoint filters, time ranges, and field values. The CLI pauses destructive actions until a person approves them. Vigil Connect extracts selected fields and the untouched raw alert from alerts; it supports Wazuh and Elastic, with Splunk and Microsoft Sentinel listed as coming soon. The Claude Code integration uses npx @vigil/skill and needs no MCP server or running process. The Apache 2.0 open-source plan is free and includes unlimited events. Enterprise support includes a dedicated Slack channel, custom integrations and SLAs, and a SOC 2 report.