Elden Ring SaveForge vs Pokémon SRM Editor
Elden Ring SaveForge
github.comPokémon SRM Editor
kasbuunk.github.ioSide by side
| Figure | Elden Ring SaveForge | Pokémon SRM Editor |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | Yes |
| Web | — | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 2 |
| Spec score · Game Save Editors | 8.3 (#7) | 8.4 (#6) |
| Diagnostics | Save diagnostics can identify inventory and storage issues and offer repair actions for supported problems. | The editor reports checksum, species, level, BCD, terminator, stale-box and level-experience problems without blocking file opening. |
| License and affiliation | The repository identifies a GPL-3.0 license and says the project is not affiliated with FromSoftware or Bandai Namco. | The project is MIT licensed, fan-made, and not affiliated with or endorsed by Nintendo, Game Freak, or The Pokémon Company. |
| Purpose | SaveForge is a desktop application for editing Elden Ring save files in .sl2 and memory.dat formats. | A save editor for Generation 1 Pokémon games Red, Blue, and Yellow. |
| Save formats | It supports reading, editing, and writing PC Steam .sl2 saves and PS4 memory.dat saves, with conversion between the two formats. | Opens raw 32 KiB `.srm` or `.sav` battery save files. |
Plans
In their own words
Elden Ring SaveForge
Elden Ring SaveForge is a free Windows desktop application for editing Elden Ring save files. It reads, edits, and writes PC Steam .sl2 and PS4 memory.dat saves, and converts between those formats. Character controls cover level, attributes, runes, NG+ cycle, class, body type, talisman slots, and memory stones. An item database supports search, categories, favorites, item details, and additions to inventory or storage with capacity checks. Save diagnostics scan for inventory problems and provide repair flows for supported issues, including quantity limits and duplicate or index problems. Safe, Expanded Limits, and Chaos profiles manage item limits and risky or cut-content items, with warnings and confirmation gates for dangerous actions. Save writes are backed up automatically, and Chaos Mode requires a separate backup gate. The project describes the application as early and unstable, warning that it can irrecoverably corrupt saves; it advises using copies rather than a main account or primary save. It is GPL-3.0 licensed, is not affiliated with FromSoftware or Bandai Namco, and lists Discord as a contact channel.
Pokémon SRM Editor
Pokémon SRM Editor is a free save editor for Generation 1 Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow. It opens raw 32 KiB `.srm` or `.sav` battery saves from emulators, flash carts, supported handheld setups, and dumped cartridges. The editor covers Pokémon in the party and all 12 PC boxes, including species, level, experience, moves, DVs, stat experience, status, trainer details, nicknames, and calculated stats. It also edits trainer identity, money, coins, badges, items, Pokédex, daycare, Hall of Fame, event flags, and other saved data. Save version history provides diffs and one-click restore. The browser edition runs through WebAssembly and does not upload save files; it keeps the original bytes downloadable. The desktop app creates a timestamped `.bak` beside the original before saving over it. Diagnostics can report checksum mismatches and invalid values without blocking opening or repair. The editor is available on web, Linux, macOS, and Windows. On OnionOS, an auto-loaded save state can shadow the battery save. The macOS app is not notarized, so its first launch needs an extra step.