ExtLume vs Monitor Switch
ExtLume
github.comMonitor Switch
github.comSide by side
| Figure | ExtLume | Monitor Switch |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | — | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | — |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| API | — | Yes |
| Self-hosted | — | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Monitor Control Software | 7.4 (#15) | 8.0 (#6) |
| Monitor controls | The app provides a separate slider for each safely identified active external display and shows its EDID model name. | It can expose monitor controls including brightness, contrast, volume, mute, picture mode, colour temperature, RGB gain, and black level. |
| Purpose | ExtLume is a Windows tray app for adjusting external monitor brightness when Windows provides a brightness slider only for the laptop panel. | Monitor Switch changes a monitor’s input source using DDC/CI, controlled through HTTP, a web UI, or Home Assistant. |
Plans
In their own words
ExtLume
ExtLume is a Windows tray app for adjusting external-monitor brightness when Windows provides a brightness control only for the laptop panel. It offers a separate slider for each safely identified active external display and shows its EDID model name. When the monitor and the full cable or dock chain support DDC/CI, the app changes the physical backlight. If that is unavailable, it can use a click-through dimming overlay on a safely isolated external desktop area; this changes the image but not backlight power. ExtLume handles multiple displays, mirrored groups, hot-plugging, and resume, while excluding built-in panels and virtual displays. It targets Windows 10 and Windows 11 and requires .NET Framework 4.8. The free, MIT-licensed public beta is available from GitHub Releases as a per-user installer or portable ZIP and requires no administrator rights. ExtLume says it works offline without telemetry or network requests. It stores limited local monitor and dimming data, and its controls are limited to brightness rather than arbitrary VCP commands, resets, or automatic display substitution.
Monitor Switch
Monitor Switch is an MIT-licensed service for switching a monitor’s input and controlling its DDC/CI features through a browser interface, HTTP API, scripts, or Home Assistant. It is designed for people who use one monitor with multiple computers, including when the computer currently displayed is asleep or off. Where a monitor exposes the controls, the service can adjust brightness, contrast, volume, mute, picture mode, colour temperature, RGB gain, and black level. It can also read usage hours, firmware level, refresh rates, and power state. Editable profiles set monitor values and can replace incorrect capability detection. For Home Assistant, MQTT discovery presents profile features as entities such as selectors, sliders, and sensors. The service runs on a Raspberry Pi connected to the monitor by HDMI; setup requires Raspberry Pi OS and SSH, and installation uses an Ansible playbook. The project is described as usable but not yet released. Hardware verification is reported only for a Samsung Odyssey G9 with a Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W; other monitors have not been verified.