ExtremeCloud IQ vs TP-Link Omada SDN
ExtremeCloud IQ
extremenetworks.com
TP-Link Omada SDN
tp-link.comSide by side
| Figure | ExtremeCloud IQ | TP-Link Omada SDN |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | — | Free |
| Free plan | — | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | — | Yes |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| iOS | — | Yes |
| Android | — | Yes |
| API | Yes | — |
| Self-hosted | Yes | — |
| Plans published | 6 | 3 |
| Spec score · Wifi Management Software | 7.4 (#7) | 7.5 (#6) |
| Spec score · Network Provisioning Software | 7.4 (#10) | 7.4 (#11) |
| Spec score · Network Management Software | 7.4 (#18) | 7.4 (#20) |
| Intended users | Extreme lists federal government, financial services, healthcare, higher education, hospitality, manufacturing, retail, and service providers among its industry solutions. | TP-Link describes Omada SDN as suited to demanding, high-traffic business environments such as campuses, hotels, malls, and offices. |
| Purpose | ExtremeCloud IQ provides machine-learning-driven unified management for access points, switches, and SD-WAN. | Omada SDN provides centralized management for enterprise networks made up of security gateways, switches, and wireless access points. |
| Third-party devices | The product manages Cisco and HPE Aruba switches and provides basic setup and monitoring for other third-party devices. | The controller guide says it cannot discover and manage third-party devices. |
Plans
ExtremeCloud IQ
- NavigatorPriced on request
- PilotPriced on request
- CoPilotPriced on request
- ExtremeCloud IQ CoPilotPriced on request
- ExtremeCloud IQ NavigatorPriced on request
- ExtremeCloud IQ PilotPriced on request
TP-Link Omada SDN
- Omada Cloud EssentialsFree
- Omada Software ControllerFree
- Omada Cloud StandardPriced on request
In their own words
ExtremeCloud IQ
ExtremeCloud IQ provides machine-learning-driven unified management for access points, switches and SD-WAN. It offers real-time and historical views of client and device health with built-in remediation tools. Automatic configuration policies, near zero-touch deployment workflows and Instant operations support onboarding and provisioning. Enhanced WiFi Maps help with network planning and optimization. The product supports OpenAPI-standard APIs for provisioning, management and customization. It can manage Cisco and HPE Aruba switches, while other third-party devices receive basic setup and monitoring. Deployment options include public cloud, private cloud and ExtremeCloud Edge; the product page describes 21 global points of presence across AWS, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud Platform. Licenses are pooled and portable across devices, locations and users, covering wired and wireless devices. Pilot includes guest management, wireless intrusion prevention and location services; CoPilot adds anomaly detection and experience monitoring. Pricing is on request, with a 90-day trial and no free plan.
TP-Link Omada SDN
TP-Link Omada SDN centralizes management of enterprise networks built from security gateways, switches and wireless access points. Administrators can configure supported Omada routers and network devices through one platform, with tools for network discovery, configuration management and backups. The hybrid deployment options include a software controller and cloud management. Omada Cloud Essentials provides free cloud management for unlimited devices, including network topology and VLAN management. Omada Cloud supports zero-touch provisioning for remote setup, and its monitoring features include network summaries and warnings about abnormal events.
The Omada app can connect to hardware, software and cloud controllers for local or remote administration. The Open API supports REST GET and POST requests, returns JSON and uses OAuth for authentication and authorization. The software controller is free for centralized management of up to 1,500 devices, with capacity dependent on PC or server hardware. Cloud Essentials is also lifetime free; Cloud Standard lists a device license fee but no price. Controller management applies only to certain TP-Link models, and the controller cannot discover or manage third-party devices.