Favicon & App Icon Generator vs MakeIcon
Favicon & App Icon Generator
favicon-generator.orgMakeIcon
makeicon.onlineSide by side
| Figure | Favicon & App Icon Generator | MakeIcon |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | — | Yes |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| iOS | Yes | Yes |
| Android | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Favicon Generators | 8.0 (#3) | 7.8 (#9) |
| Intended users | The site describes favicons for website browser identification and app icons for smartphone and tablet applications. | The maker describes MakeIcon as suited to mobile app developers, PWA creators, people making prototypes, indie developers, and designers. |
| Privacy | The linked privacy policy describes collection of device information such as IP address, browser type, cookies, page views, and interaction data, and says Google Analytics is used. | The About page says icon designs are processed in the browser and are not uploaded, stored, or tracked; AI icon prompts are sent to Cloudflare Workers AI. |
Plans
In their own words
Favicon & App Icon Generator
Favicon & App Icon Generator converts PNG, JPG, and GIF files into Windows ICO favicons and app icons for web, Android, Microsoft, and iOS projects. You can choose a single 16x16 favicon or preserve the source image’s dimensions instead of making it square. The online editor supports creating icons from scratch and adjusting generated ones with Draw, Pixel Colour, Eraser, and Reset Editor tools; JavaScript is required to use it. A public gallery is available for icons users choose to submit, with browsing by keyword, letter, and color. Generated files must be downloaded and uploaded to your own server, as the site does not host them for inline linking. Its about page provides HTML link elements for placing a favicon in a page’s document head. The Free plan costs nothing and includes image conversion, the editor, and downloads. The site also offers account registration for discussion forums and premium site features.
MakeIcon
MakeIcon creates customizable app icons for iOS, Android and web from open-source icon collections. The site lists more than 8,000 icons, including collections from Lucide, Font Awesome and Material Design. Users can change color, background, shape, gradient, padding and size, with previews on device mockups. The main generator exports PNG files or a ZIP bundle with platform sizes for iOS, Android and web. Separate AI tools generate icons and SVGs from text prompts, with SVG or PNG downloads. Liquid Glass Studio supports layered artwork, real-time WebGL2 effects, PNG exports up to 4096px and ZIP bundles with default, dark and clear variants. MakeIcon works in a browser without installation on Windows, Mac, Linux and mobile devices. Its free plan requires no signup and adds no watermark. The About page says icon designs are processed in the browser and not uploaded, stored or tracked; AI prompts go to Cloudflare Workers AI. AI use is subject to fair-use rate limits, and customized icons may be collected anonymously for the public library.