Fextralife Wikis vs LegendKeeper

Fextralife Wikis is a free web platform combining game-specific wikis, gaming news, exclusive content, and forums. Its collection includes over 150 wikis, and users can edit without an account through an editor with features tailored to each game. Pages can organize information into General, Character, Equipment, World, Guides, and Tools sections. A Dark Souls 3 wiki covers weapons, armor, skills, magic, lore, maps, walkthroughs, builds, and calculators. Interactive maps can track items, NPCs, bosses, quests, armor, and weapons. Wiki pages also link to forums, player IDs, media, and community builds, and media uploads are supported. The site says contributions use a Custom License. Wiki VIP removes ads, according to the Dark Souls 3 page. Fextralife was founded in 2012 and acquired by Valnet Inc. in December 2024. Valnet links to Facebook, X, TikTok, Twitch, and YouTube. Wiki pages provide Help and Contact links, while the audience description is “For Gamers By Gamers.”

LegendKeeper is a web-based collaborative workspace for worldbuilding and RPG campaign management. Its wiki supports nested pages, rich-text editing, auto-linking, templates, tags, and shortcuts. Maps can be nested and linked to wiki articles, with uploads up to 14K pixels and 100 MB. Timelines offer chronicle, Gantt chart, and calendar views, plus custom calendar systems and linked timelines. Collaborative whiteboards support sketches, flow charts, DM screens, and pointcrawls connected to project pages. Projects are private by default and allow real-time collaboration, public sharing, granular permissions, and secrets. Users can import Markdown, Obsidian, WorldAnvil, Google Docs, and other formats, then export projects. The browser app stores wiki and atlas edits locally for later syncing, but unsynced offline changes can be lost if browser data is cleared. LegendKeeper is not a virtual tabletop and is intended to be used alongside tools such as Foundry or Roll20. It is described as being in open beta, with some core features still planned. Basic is free; Pro costs $7.50 per month billed annually.