GameBanana vs ModBay
GameBanana
gamebanana.com
ModBay
modbay.orgSide by side
| Figure | GameBanana | ModBay |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | — | Free |
| Free plan | — | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 0 | 1 |
| Spec score · Minecraft Mod Browsers | 7.5 (#9) | 8.2 (#6) |
| Audience | The Management Initiative page says the site aims to serve PC gamers who customize their games. | The site is intended for Minecraft fans and content creators, and its terms require users to be at least 13 years old or 16 where required by law. |
| Community features | The Minecraft hub lists featured items, discussions, rules, collections and an exchange. | Accounts allow users to customize profiles, rate posts, publish posts, and participate in rankings. |
| Founded | 2001 | 2022 |
| Purpose | GameBanana hosts mods and other modding resources for Minecraft: Java Edition. | ModBay is a site dedicated to Minecraft: Bedrock Edition where users share add-ons, maps, and resource packs. |
| Support | GameBanana directs users to its Support Ticket feature for moderator help and offers a separate bug report option. | Users can contact ModBay by email or direct message on X for questions and suggestions. |
Plans
In their own words
GameBanana
GameBanana is a free web-based game modding community, with a Minecraft: Java Edition hub for mods and related resources. The hub includes tutorials, threads, works in progress, sounds, questions, requests, scripts and tools, plus featured items, discussions, collections and an exchange. Filters cover game versions and loaders such as Fabric Loader, Forge and NeoForge. GameBanana says it does not sell mods or use paywalls, and ordinary downloads do not require membership; signup is required for NSFW mods. One-click downloading integrates with more than 50 community-developed mod installers. The site documents an API authenticated with an API password, app ID and user ID, and a query parameter that can return JSON for a page module. Its guidance warns that data can change and responses may be large, so caching is needed. RSS feeds for new submissions can be filtered by game or item type. The Minecraft page requires JavaScript. Advertising covers the site’s monthly bills, while contributing members get zero ads. GameBanana describes itself as free and independent since 2001 and provides a support-ticket page.
ModBay
ModBay is a web portal and community for Minecraft: Bedrock Edition, where users find and share add-ons, maps and resource packs. Its sections also cover news, guides and seeds. Users can sort publications by date, popularity or comment count, with additional filters in content sections. The site says it checks submissions for safety, quality and compatibility with the user's game version. Downloads may be hosted on ModBay or linked externally; server uploads accept ZIP, RAR, MCPACK, MCADDON, MCTEMPLATE and MCWORLD files up to 20 MB. Accounts allow profile customization, ratings, publishing and participation in rankings. Users can register or sign in with Google or X (Twitter), and RSS feeds cover the site overall, mods and add-ons, maps, and texture packs. The site says its basic functionality is available to everyone at no cost. Its privacy policy lists account and profile information it may collect and describes session, authentication, analytics and advertising cookies. ModBay says it is not affiliated with Mojang Studios or involved in Minecraft development. The site was founded in 2022.