Google Cloud Batch vs HCL Workload Automation
Google Cloud Batch
cloud.google.comHCL Workload Automation
hcl-software.comSide by side
| Figure | Google Cloud Batch | HCL Workload Automation |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | — |
| Free plan | Yes | — |
| Free trial | — | Yes |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | — | Yes |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| API | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | — | Yes |
| Plans published | 2 | 1 |
| Spec score · Job Scheduler Software | 8.7 (#3) | 8.6 (#4) |
| Integrations | Google lists Cloud Storage, Pub/Sub, Cloud Logging and Workflows as native Batch integrations. | Documented integrations include Jira, ServiceNow, RESTful APIs, JSONata, and IBM Robotic Process Automation. |
| Monitoring | Batch can send job and task state change notifications through Pub/Sub, and those notifications can be streamed to BigQuery for analysis. | The product includes graphical views, embedded analytics, and customizable dashboards for managing and monitoring jobs and job streams. |
| Operating systems | Supported Batch image families include Batch Debian, Container-Optimized OS and HPC Rocky Linux; GA Compute Engine images include Debian and Rocky Linux. | The 10.2.7 operating systems report lists Linux and Windows support, and macOS support for Orchestration CLI. |
| Security | Batch supports IAM permissions and VPC Service Controls, and its documentation describes using Secret Manager to provide sensitive job data. | Fresh installations automatically encrypt key product files at rest using AES-256 or AES-128 cryptography; encryption can be disabled during installation. |
| Support | Batch users can consult community forums and troubleshooting documentation; direct Google Cloud Support for Batch issues requires a paid support package. | HCL’s product documentation page links to HCLSoftware Support, a knowledge base, a community, and a product ideas portal. |
Plans
In their own words
Google Cloud Batch
Google Cloud Batch schedules, queues, and runs batch jobs on Google infrastructure. It obtains resources for jobs, creates or removes them during runtime to match job specifications, and can scale compute resources automatically for parallel work. Jobs run executable scripts or containerized workloads, with tasks arranged sequentially or in parallel. Storage options include persistent disks, local SSDs, Cloud Storage buckets, and network file systems such as Filestore. Integrations identified for a developer workflow include Cloud Storage, Pub/Sub, Cloud Logging, and Workflows. Batch can send job and task state changes through Pub/Sub, with notifications streamable to BigQuery. It supports IAM permissions and VPC Service Controls; Secret Manager can provide sensitive job data. Batch itself has no additional charge, but resources used by jobs are billed, and quotas and limits apply. Each job is restricted to one task group, named group0, and finished jobs are automatically deleted after 60 days unless deleted earlier. It is available through API and web, with cloud deployment.
HCL Workload Automation
HCL Workload Automation is software for defining, scheduling, managing, and monitoring critical batch processes. It groups scheduled jobs into job streams and supports dependencies, time constraints, and automatic recovery procedures. Graphical views, embedded analytics, and customizable dashboards help teams follow jobs and streams. Event rules can trigger jobs, respond to prompts, notify users of anomalies, or invoke an external product when conditions occur. Documented integrations include Jira, ServiceNow, RESTful APIs, JSONata, and IBM Robotic Process Automation; HCL says Automation Hub provides over 100 plugins at no additional cost. Tasks can run through local agents, without agents, or through APIs, and the product supports container and hybrid deployments, including Docker, Red Hat OpenShift, and a cloud-native service in a customer-chosen cloud. Pricing is available on request, and HCL advertises a 90-day free trial. From version 10.2, customers need their own WebSphere Application Server Liberty and Db2 licenses to keep using them.