Google Cloud Identity vs Shibboleth
Google Cloud Identity
cloud.google.comShibboleth
shibboleth.netSide by side
| Figure | Google Cloud Identity | Shibboleth |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | $6/mo | $279.50/mo |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | Yes | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | — |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| iOS | Yes | — |
| Android | Yes | — |
| API | Yes | — |
| Self-hosted | — | Yes |
| Plans published | 7 | 10 |
| Spec score · Single Sign-On Software | 9.2 (#2) | 7.8 (#21) |
| Purpose | Cloud Identity centrally manages users and groups as an Identity as a Service solution. | Shibboleth provides identity management software for individual organisations and multi-site federations. |
| Single sign-on | The product provides SSO to thousands of cloud and on-premises applications. | Its Identity Provider provides a flexible Single Sign-On solution for complex identity management requirements. |
| Support | The editions page lists 24x7 chat and email support for Premium and Google Cloud Communities for Free. | General users can use Wiki documentation, community forums and mailing lists, while Consortium members receive developer Q&A and members-only Slack support. |
Plans
Google Cloud Identity
- Cloud Identity Premium — Annual/Fixed-Term Plan$6 a month
- Cloud Identity Premium — Flexible Plan$7.20 a month
- Cloud Identity FreeFree
- Cloud Identity FreeFree
- Cloud Identity Premium$7.20 a month
- Cloud Identity Premium Flexible$7.20 a month
- Cloud Identity Premium Annual/Fixed-Term$72 a year
Shibboleth
- Shibboleth softwareFree
- Academic/Non-Profit Small$3,354 a year
- Academic/Non-Profit Medium$6,707 a year
- Commercial Small$6,707 a year
- Academic/Non-Profit Large$10,061 a year
- Commercial Medium$13,415 a year
- NREN/Federation Small$15,244 a year
- Commercial Large$26,829 a year
- NREN/Federation Medium$30,488 a year
- NREN/Federation Large$60,976 a year
In their own words
Google Cloud Identity
Google Cloud Identity centrally manages users and groups as an Identity as a Service solution. It can federate identities between Google and providers such as Active Directory and Microsoft Entra ID, and provides single sign-on to thousands of SaaS applications, including Salesforce, SAP SuccessFactors, and Google Workspace. MFA choices include push notifications, Google Authenticator, Titan Security Keys, security keys, backup codes, SMS, voice calls, passkeys, and other TOTP code generators. Its console manages Android, iOS, and Windows devices, with tools to enforce policies, wipe company data, deploy apps, and view reports. Automated provisioning can create, update, or delete user profile information in third-party cloud applications. Directory Sync extends Active Directory users to the cloud, while Secure LDAP supports traditional applications and infrastructure. Free includes 50 user licenses by default; additional licenses can be requested at no cost. Premium costs $6 a month on an annual fixed-term plan, or $7.20 a month on a flexible plan billed monthly. Premium also lists a 99.9% SLA and 24x7 chat and email support.
Shibboleth
Shibboleth is open-source identity management software for individual organizations and multi-site federations. Its Identity Provider offers single sign-on for complex identity needs, supports multiple authentication systems, and can handle millions of authentication requests per day. Authentication and data handling features are customizable. The Service Provider works with a wide range of web applications, integrates with popular web servers, and provides policy-oriented authorization features. An Embedded Discovery Service helps users choose an Identity Provider from a shorter list and supports screen readers. The Metadata Aggregator verifies signed metadata, filters selected elements, and provides a web service for querying processed metadata. Shibboleth supports SAML 1.1, SAML 2.0, OpenID Connect, and CAS, along with LDAP and Kerberos directory integrations. Built-in MFA and adaptive access are listed, while lifecycle provisioning is not included. The software is free to download and use, with Linux, macOS, Windows, and self-hosted platforms listed. General users can consult wiki documentation, forums, and mailing lists; Consortium members also receive developer Q&A and members-only Slack support. The project recommends Identity Provider version 5.2.2 or later for a May 2026 XML parsing vulnerability.