GtkRadiant vs J.A.C.K.
GtkRadiant
icculus.orgJ.A.C.K.
jack.hlfx.ruSide by side
| Figure | GtkRadiant | J.A.C.K. |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | — |
| Free plan | Yes | — |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | Yes | — |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 2 | 1 |
| Spec score · Game Level Editors | 8.6 (#3) | 7.6 (#14) |
| Development | The source is on GitHub, where developers can fork the project, make changes, and submit pull requests. | The maker says J.A.C.K. has been in development since August 2013. |
| Extensibility | The project encourages teams to fork and modify the GitHub source for advanced needs that the main release does not cover. | Plugins can add capabilities such as brush primitives, texture and model formats, and game configurations with import and export formats. |
| Intended users | The project describes its audience as commercial developers and individual modders making levels for supported id Tech games. | The editor aims to serve people designing levels for classic games and mods, including Quake and Half-Life. |
| Purpose | GtkRadiant is an open-source, cross-platform level editor and toolchain for games powered by id Tech engines. | J.A.C.K. is a level editor for games using Quake-style BSP architecture. |
| Support | Support options listed by the project include forums, IRC, tutorial sites, and a GitHub issue tracker. | Users can submit error reports and feature requests through the project forums; the software is provided without warranty. |
| Supported games | Current 1.6 documentation lists Quake, Quake II, Quake II Remastered, Quake III Arena, Quake Live, Quetoo, Urban Terror, Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory, Return to Castle Wolfenstein, Star Trek Voyager: Elite Force and Jedi Academy. | The editor supports Quake, Half-Life, Quake II, Quake III, and Hexen II. |
Plans
In their own words
GtkRadiant
GtkRadiant is a free, open-source level editor and toolchain for games powered by id Tech engines. It includes map compilers, data authoring tools, and Q3Map2, with tools for 3D levels, terrain, and entity placement. The GtkRadiant 1.6 page lists support for games including Quake III Arena, QuakeLive, Urban Terror, Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory, Quake2, Quake2: Remastered, Quetoo, Return to Castle Wolfenstein, Star Trek Voyager: Elite Force, and Jedi Academy. Support for a game can depend on an active developer to test and address issues; some titles may require an older version or third-party fork. GtkRadiant reads and writes assets in a game's directory, and the project recommends installing the game first. It runs on Linux, macOS, and Windows. Linux distribution is through Flathub as a Flatpak; the Mac version requires XQuartz, MacPorts, and other dependencies. Volunteers maintain the GPL-licensed project, which is provided as-is without warranty or support. Listed help options include forums, IRC, tutorial sites, and a GitHub issue tracker.