Harbor vs Inedo ProGet

Harbor is an open-source registry for managing artifacts across cloud-native platforms such as Kubernetes and Docker. It offers a web UI and extensible API, and can be installed on Kubernetes or a system with Docker support. Security features include policies, role-based access control, vulnerability scanning, and image signing and validation. Image scanning uses Trivy when enabled during installation, and Harbor can connect to additional scanners. It replicates images and charts to or from other registries in pull or push mode; listed adapters include Docker Hub, Amazon ECR, Google Container Registry, Azure Container Registry, and GitLab Registry. Authentication options are database, LDAP/Active Directory, and OIDC, though choosing database authentication and adding local users prevents a later switch to another mode. Project storage quotas are unlimited by default but can be set globally or per project. Robot account secrets are not stored by Harbor, so they must be saved when created; robot accounts cannot log into the user interface. Harbor is a CNCF Graduated project. HTTPS is recommended for production use.

Inedo ProGet is a package and container repository for teams that need a central place to manage software packages and Docker images. It supports formats including NuGet, PyPI, Conda, npm, Ruby Gems, Maven, Chocolatey, PowerShell/DSC, RPM/Yum, Debian/apt, and Alpine/APK. Teams can cache upstream packages, set approval workflows, scan for vulnerabilities, identify licenses, and block packages that fail their requirements. ProGet can host private Docker registries and scan container contents to help control which images reach production. It integrates with CI/CD tools and includes a CLI and HTTP API for component identification and SBOM publishing. Deployment options include self-hosted Windows or Linux installations and cloud VM or container environments. Identity and operational features include LDAP, SAML, load balancing, high availability, and feed replication for disaster recovery. The free edition permits commercial use and unlimited feeds for private packages and Docker, but has limited security and compliance features. Paid annual plans start at $2,395/year. Licensing is per server, and test or development installations require separate licenses.