HID Approve vs Proton Authenticator
HID Approve
hidglobal.comProton Authenticator
proton.meSide by side
| Figure | HID Approve | Proton Authenticator |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | — | Free |
| Free plan | — | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| iOS | Yes | Yes |
| Android | Yes | Yes |
| API | Yes | — |
| Plans published | 1 | 2 |
| Spec score · Authenticator apps | 7.9 (#59) | 8.8 (#9) |
| Code type | totp and hotp | totp |
| Headquarters | Austin, Texas, United States | Plan-les-Ouates, Geneva, Switzerland |
| Purpose | HID Approve provides mobile authentication and transaction signing for consumer and workforce use cases. | Proton Authenticator generates time-based, one-time 2FA codes on your device for an extra layer of account login security. |
| Security | HID describes the solution as using standards-based cryptography and says it is backed by third-party penetration testing and independent audit reviews. | Proton says that synced data is end-to-end encrypted and that its servers never access the unencrypted data. |
| Support | HID identity and authentication support includes HID Approve and provides Europe and US customer-service phone numbers. | The product page links to Proton product support. |
| Supported platforms | Android,iOS,macOS,Windows | iOS,Android,macOS,Windows,Linux |
Plans
In their own words
HID Approve
HID Approve provides mobile authentication and transaction signing for consumer and workforce services. Users can approve access requests or sign transactions on a mobile device using push notifications, QR codes, or one-time passwords. Password generation supports TOTP and HOTP, and one-time passwords can be used when the device is offline. Consumer scenarios include banking transaction signing, payment approval, Strong Customer Authentication, and secure login to digital financial services. Workforce scenarios include VPN and remote-access authentication, corporate and cloud application access, and regulated workflows. Organizations can deploy it as a customizable mobile app or integrate it into existing applications through an authentication SDK. The SDK connects to ActivID Authentication Server, ActivID Appliance, or HID Authentication Service; the cloud service exposes a REST API for managing device types, credential types, and authentication policies. HID lists Android, iOS, macOS, and Windows support, including a standalone Windows .NET installer. The product supports team administration and directory sync. Pricing is on request, and there is no free plan.
Proton Authenticator
Proton Authenticator generates time-based one-time codes for two-factor authentication, adding a code at login to help secure accounts. It can display codes without an internet connection, and a Proton Account is not required to use it. Signing in is optional and enables code syncing across devices. Users can import codes from Google Authenticator, 2FAS, Aegis Authenticator, Bitwarden Authenticator, Ente Auth, and LastPass Authenticator, then export their codes from the app. Backups can be stored locally or in the cloud, with end-to-end encrypted sync between devices. Proton says its servers cannot access synced data in unencrypted form; when sync is on, entries are protected with 256-bit AES-GCM. The app is open source, and its vault can be unlocked with face or fingerprint recognition. It is available for Android, iOS, Linux, macOS, and Windows; Android is also available through F-Droid. Proton Authenticator is free on all listed platforms, with no ads or tracking.