LALAL.AI vs StemDeck

LALAL.AI uses AI to separate vocals and instrument stems, clean voice recordings, change or clone voices, and reduce echo and reverb. Its available stem types include vocals, instrumental, drums, bass, electric and acoustic guitar, piano, synthesizer, strings, and wind instruments. The web vocal remover accepts audio and video formats, including MP3, WAV, FLAC, MP4, and MOV. Fast Queue prioritizes processing, while Relaxed Queue processes as server capacity allows; both provide the same separation quality. Usage minutes are calculated by multiplying file length by the number of selected stem types. The desktop app supports Windows, macOS, and Ubuntu Linux, with batch processing for up to 20 files; Pro subscribers can optionally process locally offline. The API and VST plugin offer other ways to use the tools. The free Starter plan includes 10 Relaxed Queue minutes, but does not allow full downloads. Lite costs $7.50 a month billed annually.

StemDeck separates songs into stems for practice, study, transcription, remixing, and other creative audio work. Its Demucs htdemucs_6s model separates vocals, drums, bass, guitar, piano, and other sounds. Files accepted include MP3, WAV, FLAC, OGG/Opus, MP4, and M4A, and songs can also be supplied by YouTube URL. The workspace provides waveform lanes, mute and solo controls, volume adjustment, and looping; users can export individual stems or a custom mix in WAV or MP3. Song analysis includes BPM, key, scale, confidence, integrated LUFS, and sample peak level. StemDeck says audio processing runs locally and the app does not transmit, store, cache, or redistribute audio. Internet access is needed for YouTube downloads and an initial model fetch of about 170 MB, which is cached afterward. The project documents Docker and Unraid deployment, source-based web-server use, and a local REST API. It is free, with no account, quota, uploads, or subscription, but handles one job at a time, supports up to six stems, and has no mobile app.