MagicPlayer vs MediaSage
MagicPlayer
magicplayer.aiMediaSage
github.comSide by side
| Figure | MagicPlayer | MediaSage |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | — |
| Free plan | Yes | — |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | — | Yes |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | — | Yes |
| API | — | Yes |
| Self-hosted | — | Yes |
| Plans published | 8 | 0 |
| Spec score · AI Music Playlist Generators | 8.7 (#4) | 7.4 (#19) |
Plans
MagicPlayer
- FreeFree
- FreeFree
- Composer$9, paid once
- Composer$9, paid once
- Conductor$19, paid once
- Conductor$19, paid once
- Maestro$29, paid once
- Maestro$29, paid once
In their own words
MagicPlayer
MagicPlayer is a web app for generating and editing music playlists from descriptions of the listening experience a user wants. Prompts can specify mood, activity, genre, artists or a broader vibe; Quick Mode builds from preferences, while Creative Mode gives users a way to make personal playlists. Recommendation settings can lean toward popular tracks, balance familiar artists with hidden gems, or favor musical surprises. Playlists contain 20 songs by default, with options to request another length or extend a playlist. Users can edit, add tracks and share playlists, then return shared visibility to private. Playlists sync across devices, with access described for desktop, tablet and mobile. Exports are available to YouTube and YouTube Music; Spotify export support is in preview. Each suggested or added song uses one Track Recommendation credit, while listening to or reusing an added track uses none. Free includes 200 credits. Composer costs $9, paid once for 2,000 recommendations, Conductor is $19, paid once for 5,000, and Maestro is $29, paid once for 10,000.
MediaSage
MediaSage is a free, MIT-licensed self-hosted web app for building Plex playlists and recommending albums from a music library. Users can describe a playlist in natural language or start with a selected song; prompts can include mood, era, instrumentation, genre, production style, and a seed track. Album suggestions can focus on owned albums or look beyond the library. Filters cover library genres, decades, minimum rating, and excluding live recordings. The app syncs Plex music data to a local SQLite database for filtering and track selection. Users can preview tracks, create or update playlists, and send tracks to active Plex clients. It works with Google Gemini, Anthropic Claude, OpenAI GPT, Ollama, and custom OpenAI-compatible APIs, and displays estimated provider costs before generation. Setup requires Docker or Python 3.11 or newer, a Plex server containing music, a Plex token, and an AI provider key or local model. The maker documents Linux, macOS, and Windows use, with NAS instructions for Synology, Unraid, and TrueNAS SCALE. Approximate provider capacity limits are listed, and local model support is described as experimental.