Mailoney vs OpenCanary
Mailoney
github.comOpenCanary
github.comSide by side
| Figure | Mailoney | OpenCanary |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | — | Free |
| Free plan | — | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Windows | Yes | — |
| macOS | — | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 0 | 1 |
| Spec score · Honeypot Software | 6.9 (#18) | 8.2 (#2) |
| Deployment | The project documents Docker and Docker Compose deployment, plus local installation from the Python package source. | The project documents installation on Ubuntu and macOS, plus Docker deployment on Linux hosts using host networking. |
| License | The repository identifies Mailoney as MIT-licensed. | The PyPI listing identifies OpenCanary as OSI Approved BSD licensed software. |
| Purpose | Mailoney is a low-interaction SMTP honeypot that simulates a vulnerable mail server to detect and log unauthorized access attempts, credential harvesting, and other SMTP-based attacks. | OpenCanary is a multi-protocol network honeypot intended to detect attackers interacting with services on non-public networks. |
| Security guidance | The project advises deploying the honeypot in a controlled environment, limiting privileges, and configuring a firewall to prevent misuse. | The project recommends making the configuration file root-owned and writable only by root because writable configuration can allow privilege escalation. |
Plans
In their own words
Mailoney
Mailoney is a self-hosted SMTP honeypot for recording attempts to access a simulated vulnerable mail server. It listens on port 25 and captures authentication attempts and credentials. Session data can be stored in SQLite, PostgreSQL, or MySQL/MariaDB, or the database can be disabled for event-only logging; PostgreSQL is recommended for production. By default, captured email bodies are discarded. Setting MAILONEY_MAIL_DIR enables writing them to disk. Events can be emitted as JSON Lines for forwarding to log shippers and security tools, including SIEM, ELK Stack, or Loki. An optional Prometheus endpoint reports connection, session, credential, command, and duration metrics. STARTTLS is available when a certificate and matching private key are configured, with TLS 1.2 as the minimum. Deployment options include Docker, Docker Compose, or local Python installation. It supports Linux and Windows and is distributed under the MIT License. The project advises controlled deployment, limited privileges, and firewall configuration; its unauthenticated metrics endpoint should not be exposed to the internet.
OpenCanary
OpenCanary is free, self-hosted software that acts as a network honeypot, imitating services so it can alert when someone interacts with them after entering a non-public network. It runs as a daemon and can report details such as a source IP address and a possible breach location. Service modules cover SSH, FTP, Git, web protocols, databases, Telnet, SNMP, SIP, VNC, Redis, TFTP, NTP, and TCP banners. Alerts can go to files, Syslog, email, HTTP webhooks, Slack, Microsoft Teams, or HPFeeds-compatible daemons. Its companion correlator can combine related events into a single email or SMS alert. The project says it has very low resource requirements and can run on a Raspberry Pi or a minimally resourced virtual machine. Documentation covers Ubuntu, macOS, and Docker on Linux hosts. Linux supports the broadest set of options: SMB monitoring is unavailable on macOS, and portscan monitoring is Linux-only and disabled in Docker. The project advises restricting write access to its configuration file because it is read with root privileges.