NeoCD/PS2 vs NeoGeo CD Redux
NeoCD/PS2
github.comNeoGeo CD Redux
github.comSide by side
| Figure | NeoCD/PS2 | NeoGeo CD Redux |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Neo Geo Emulators | 7.8 (#4) | 7.7 (#6) |
| Audio | Features include stereo sound emulation and CDDA support. | The changelog notes MP3 playback from SD and DVD and describes a later audio fix as experimental. |
| BIOS requirement | A NeoGeo CD BIOS is required and is not provided with the emulator. | The changelog says the BIOS must be located on the chosen media and lists /neocd/bios/NeoCD.bin and /bios/NeoCD.bin as search locations. |
| Controllers | It supports two controllers. | The Wii changelog lists support for Wiimote, Nunchuck, Classic Controller, and GameCube controllers under the stated detection condition. |
| Purpose | NeoCD/PS2 is an open-source NeoGeo CD emulator for the Sony PlayStation 2. | The repository describes NeoGeo CD Redux as a NeoGeo CD emulator. |
| Video | Features include PAL/NTSC auto-detection and selection. | The changelog lists progressive video and component-cable auto-detection for 480i/480p and 576i/576p modes. |
| Video modes | It offers PAL/NTSC auto-detection and a selector for video mode. | The changelog documents progressive video support and lists 480i/480p and 576i/576p modes. |
Plans
In their own words
NeoCD/PS2
NeoCD/PS2 is a free, open-source NeoGeo CD emulator for the Sony PlayStation 2. It is a port of NeoCD/SDL, adapted to replace SDL components with PS2-native libraries using PS2SDK. Games load directly from the CD-ROM. Video offers PAL/NTSC auto-detection and selection, while the in-game menu includes filtering, fullscreen video, and frameskip controls. The emulator supports two controllers, stereo sound emulation, and CDDA playback. NeoGeo CD memory card support uses 45 KB on a PS2 memory card. ZIP support is limited to the BIOS, and the NeoGeo CD BIOS is not included; users must find it or dump it from their own system. The releases page lists version 0.6c with CDDA fixes, including an auto-loop feature. Listed issues include sound problems when the frame rate is below full speed, timing issues, graphics glitches in some games, and needing to reset the PS2 to exit the BIOS. The project is distributed under GNU General Public License version 2 and says use is at the user's own risk; the README says it should only be used with games the user legally owns.
NeoGeo CD Redux
NeoGeo CD Redux is an open-source NeoGeo CD emulator with build targets for Nintendo GameCube and Wii. The Wii target runs natively rather than requiring GameCube mode. It loads game media from SD cards and DVDs, with USB loading on Wii, plus FAT-formatted SD access through WKF and FAT-formatted hard-drive access through IDE-EXI. Wii controller options listed are Wii Remote, Nunchuck, Classic Controller, and GameCube controllers when the stated detection condition is met. Video output includes progressive modes and 480i, 480p, 576i, and 576p, with component-cable detection. MP3 playback from SD and DVD is documented. Save files can use SD storage or a memory card, while WKF and IDE-EXI write support was not included in the listed release. The project lists .bin/.cue, .img, and .iso images. It is free, and the latest changelog entry is unofficial version 0.1.52A.2 from July 18, 2013.