ngspice vs QElectroTech
ngspice
ngspice.sourceforge.ioQElectroTech
qelectrotech.orgSide by side
| Figure | ngspice | QElectroTech |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | Free |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | — |
| Plans published | 1 | 1 |
| Spec score · Electrical Design Software | 8.2 (#12) | 7.5 (#27) |
| Purpose | ngspice is an open-source simulator for electric and electronic circuits. | QElectroTech is free software for creating complex industrial electrical diagrams. |
| Support | The project offers mailing lists, discussion forums, a bug tracker, an FAQ, and documentation. | The project directs people with questions to its forum and also lists a dedicated IRC channel. |
Plans
In their own words
ngspice
ngspice is a free, open-source simulator for electric and electronic circuits described as netlists. It handles analog, digital, and mixed-signal designs, with models for active, passive, analog, and digital elements; model parameters can come from collections, manufacturers, or foundries. Its SPICE compatibility supports PSPICE or LTSPICE device model parameters and netlists for discrete circuits. For mixed-signal co-simulation, it supports Verilog blocks compiled with Verilator and, since ngspice-44, VHDL blocks using GHDL. The OSDI/OpenVAF interface connects Verilog-A compact device models without requiring programming on the ngspice side. It can also be built as a shared library or DLL for another application to control. Listed integrations include KiCad, Autodesk Fusion, and Python interfaces such as PySpice. ngspice does not include schematic entry: input is through the command line or files. The stable download page offers source archives and Windows binaries; Linux users are directed to their distributor or source compilation, and the project's own macOS release is unavailable there.
QElectroTech
QElectroTech is free desktop software for creating complex industrial electrical diagrams, available for Linux, macOS, and Windows. Its symbol collection contains over 8,000 symbols, including electrical, logic, pneumatic, hydraulic, and fluid symbols. Users can place elements by drag and drop; conductors connect aligned elements automatically, and linked elements can show cross references that update with the project. An embedded editor lets users create custom symbols or other elements and store them in a user collection. Projects can be printed or saved as PDF, and drawings exported as SVG, PNG, JPG, or BMP. Element information can be exported to CSV for spreadsheet editing and parts lists. The project says files can move among its supported desktop operating systems without conversion or restriction. It can also be used for plumbing, geothermal, air-conditioning, hydraulics, pneumatics, home automation, PID, and photovoltaic diagrams. QElectroTech supports DXF but not native DWG, and the project says it does not perform simulation or calculations. It is GNU/GPL software with no licensing fees; questions can be directed to its forum or IRC channel.