NIPAP vs Subnetly

NIPAP is a self-hosted IP address management system for large address inventories. It offers a web interface and a feature-complete command-line tool, and can allocate the next available address automatically. Search supports IP prefix operators and regular expressions. IPv6 has feature parity with IPv4, and VRFs are supported natively. The system also includes subnet planning, integrated statistics, and audit history. Address data is stored and indexed in PostgreSQL with the ip4r module. The backend communicates through an XML-RPC API, and the project lists Python and Java client libraries. NIPAP is open source under the MIT license and is free. Debian and Debian derivatives are officially supported; the maker says other Unix-like systems may run it with manual dependency installation. Installation involves configuring authentication accounts for both the backend and web interface. The maker describes user documentation as rather limited and directs users to GitHub issues for bugs, feature requests, and other issues.

Subnetly is a hybrid SaaS DDI platform for DNS, DHCP, IP address management, network discovery, and network visibility. Its dashboard records IP use and ownership, identifies conflicts and orphaned addresses, and can export QBR data. Local agents manage authoritative DNS zones and DHCP scopes, with a SaaS console coordinating records and configurations. Agents scan active network segments using ARP, SNMP, and ICMP to build a hardware asset registry. Subnetly says its AI insights can identify capacity risks and configuration gaps as well as address issues. Deployment options include Docker, Kubernetes/Helm, Windows Server, and a Linux daemon. The company says agents communicate outbound over HTTPS or TLS without open inbound ports or VPN tunnels. REST APIs and monitoring webhooks support third-party automation, though access varies by paid tier. MSP controls cover customer and site separation, technician roles, and audit records. A free plan is available; paid plans start at $49 a month. Starter and Pro include 14-day trials, Business has a 21-day trial, and signup requires no credit card.