Octobar vs Vanilla

Octobar is a menu bar app for macOS with more than 16 tools, including desktop organization, system controls, file and app access, shortcuts, translation and utilities. Its modules include Tidy Desktop, Stay Awake, Hide Notch, Pack Menu, Connected Devices, Open Folder, Run Shortcut, Open App, Open Webpage, What's My IP, Translate, Read QR Code, Color Picker, New File from Finder, Lock Keyboard and Snippets. Run Shortcut can launch a macOS Shortcut by name. Translate uses Apple's on-device framework, though macOS may use Apple's online service if an on-device model is unavailable for a language pair. Octobar requires macOS 15 Sequoia or later and Apple Silicon, and is distributed through the Mac App Store. The free plan supports up to five active modules and includes the full catalog and free updates. Octobar Pro is 4.99 USD once, adding unlimited active modules, submenu groups, future modules and Family Sharing for up to six people. The maker says normal operation collects no personal data; configuration and preferences are stored locally. Some modules contact the internet for their stated functions.

Vanilla hides menu bar icons on macOS. Its free plan covers icon hiding; the $10.00 USD one-time Pro purchase adds shortcuts for toggling menu bar and desktop icons, automatic hiding five seconds after toggling, and the option to start at login. Pro can also place icons in a “Completely Removed” section, where they are visible only in Vanilla’s preferences window. A Pro activation code can be used up to 10 times by default. On macOS Catalina and later, hiding icons requires Screen Recording permission. The maker says Vanilla takes menu bar screenshots for this function, but does not save or transmit them. It says internet access is limited to checking for updates and validating Pro codes. Vanilla supports MacBooks with display notches, though setup may involve rearranging menu bar items. The maker offers email support and suggests including device and operating system details in help requests. Vanilla is identified as Matthew Palmer’s product, and the product site dates to 2017.