PunishBAN vs PunishmentSystem
PunishBAN
github.comPunishmentSystem
github.comSide by side
| Figure | PunishBAN | PunishmentSystem |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | — | — |
| Free plan | — | — |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | — | — |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 0 | 0 |
| Spec score · Minecraft Moderation Plugins | 6.9 (#10) | 6.8 (#11) |
| License | The project is licensed under MIT. | The project states that it is licensed under GNU General Public License V3. |
| Punishments | It supports bans and mutes for online and offline players, with presets and custom durations. | It supports bans, temporary bans, mutes, kicks, and unbans. |
| Purpose | PunishBAN is a lightweight punishment plugin for Paper servers. | PunishmentSystem is a Minecraft punishment management plugin with a GUI, Discord integration, and ban evasion detection. |
| Requirements | It requires Paper 1.21.1 or newer and Java 21 or newer. | The stated requirements are Minecraft 1.21+, Java 11+, EssentialsX, and Paper, Spigot, or Folia server software. |
| Support | The Modrinth listing links to a Discord server and the source repository. | The maintainer directs users to open repository issues or contact Kanuunankuula [If_Master] on Discord for support, bug reports, and feature requests. |
In their own words
PunishBAN
PunishBAN is a lightweight punishment plugin for self-hosted Paper Minecraft servers. It handles bans and mutes for players who are online or offline, using presets or custom durations and reasons. Its chat filter checks configured terms without regard to capitalization and normalizes leetspeak. Staff can receive clickable ban and mute alerts, with a cooldown to limit repeated notifications. Three filter violations within 24 hours trigger an automatic 24-hour ban; a violation in the racism category results in a permanent ban on the first offense. The `/playerinfo` command shows a player's UUID, first and last login, punishment status and alternate accounts that share an IP. `/banlogs` displays ban and mute history, listing the last 10 entries. Presets, filter terms and durations can be configured in `config.yml`. The plugin stores data in YAML files and does not require a database. It supports English and German, which can be switched without restarting. Its requirements are Paper 1.21.1+ and Java 21+; LuckPerms is recommended for permission management.
PunishmentSystem
PunishmentSystem is a free, open-source Minecraft server plugin for administering player discipline through a graphical interface. It supports bans, temporary bans, mutes, kicks, and unbans, while maintaining searchable punishment histories with pagination, filters, and export options. Release 1.1.0 lists a database, case and points systems, a case-lookup plugin, and an API. Discord notifications can include the punishment type, reason, staff member, duration, timestamp, player details, and server name. Ban-evasion detection tracks IP addresses, compares banned players with new joiners, alerts staff with the required permission, and records suspected attempts. The README lists EssentialsX integration and support for Paper, Spigot, and Folia servers running Minecraft 1.21 or later with Java 11 or later. Bedrock Edition players can use a configurable prefix. The project says punishment data uses AES-256 encryption, secure key handling, tamper protection, and automatic backups. It is self-hosted and licensed under GPL v3.