Shroud.email vs SimpleLogin
Shroud.email
shroud.email
SimpleLogin
simplelogin.ioSide by side
| Figure | Shroud.email | SimpleLogin |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | $2.92/mo | $3/mo |
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | Yes | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | — |
| iOS | — | Yes |
| Android | — | Yes |
| API | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 4 | 2 |
| Spec score · Email Alias Services | 8.7 (#5) | 8.2 (#11) |
| Account security | Passkeys and authenticator-app two-factor authentication are supported, and passwords are salted and hashed. | Accounts can be secured with TOTP and/or WebAuthn (FIDO) two-factor authentication. |
| Custom domains | Paid accounts can use owned domains, configure catch-all aliases, and recreate those addresses elsewhere later. | Users can bring their own domain to create aliases and use catch-all addresses. |
| Headquarters | The operator’s registered office is Third Floor, 3 Hill Street, New Town, Edinburgh, EH2 3JP. | Plan-les-Ouates, Switzerland |
| Open source | The maker describes the project as open source under the AGPL v3 and provides a Docker Compose deployment for self-hosting. | The service says its components are open source, and that it can be self-hosted. |
| Support | Users can ask general questions in GitHub Discussions, report technical issues through GitHub, or contact the maker by email or the site chat. | The site directs users to email [email protected] or post questions in its forum. |
| What it does | Shroud.email creates aliases that forward messages to a real inbox while hiding the user’s primary address. | SimpleLogin provides email aliases that forward messages to your inbox and let you reply or send mail while keeping your real address hidden. |
Plans
In their own words
Shroud.email
Shroud.email creates email aliases that forward incoming messages to your real inbox, keeping the real address private. It removes tracking pixels from forwarded mail and proxies email images through its servers. You can delete or disable aliases and block individual senders, and the service says it works with all email providers, including Gmail and Proton Mail. Paid users can attach custom domains, configure catch-all aliases, and recreate those addresses elsewhere if they leave. The API manages aliases and discovers custom domains with bearer-token authorization. The project is open source under AGPL v3 and includes a Docker Compose deployment for self-hosting. Self-hosting requires a public server with ports 25, 80, and 443 open, plus keys for S3-compatible storage. Detected spam remains viewable in the web portal for seven days. The hosted service is EU-hosted on renewable energy. The Free plan costs nothing and includes five aliases and tracker blocking; the paid plan has no listed price and renews annually.
SimpleLogin
SimpleLogin creates email aliases that forward messages to a mailbox while keeping a user's real address hidden. Users can reply to messages or send mail from an alias. Aliases can be created with a subdomain or catch-all domain, and users can bring their own domain. With PGP enabled, messages are encrypted with the user's PGP key before forwarding. Accounts support TOTP and/or WebAuthn two-factor authentication. SimpleLogin says its components are open source and can be self-hosted. It lists Chrome, Firefox, and Safari extensions, plus iOS and Android apps, including Android through F-Droid. The Free plan costs nothing and includes 10 aliases, one mailbox, and unlimited bandwidth; users cannot create more aliases after reaching the cap. Premium costs $36/year or $4 billed monthly, and includes unlimited aliases, custom domains, and mailboxes, plus PGP encryption. Free and Premium plans include the corresponding Proton Pass features. SimpleLogin says it joined Proton in early 2022.