Skip to content
SPECIFICTION
Get listed

cnc-ddraw vs vkd3d-proton

cnc-ddraw

github.com

vkd3d-proton

github.com

Side by side

Figurecnc-ddrawvkd3d-proton
Price fromFreeFree
Free planYesYes
Free trial——
Open sourceYes—
WindowsYesYes
macOSYes—
LinuxYesYes
AndroidYes—
Self-hostedYes—
Plans published11
Spec score · Game Compatibility Layers9.0 (#1)7.1 (#22)
Purposecnc-ddraw reimplements the DirectDraw API to improve compatibility in older 2D games that have issues such as black screens, poor performance, crashes, or defective Alt+Tab behavior.vkd3d-proton aims to implement the full Direct3D 12 API on top of Vulkan and provides Direct3D 12 support development for Proton.

Plans

cnc-ddraw

  • cnc-ddrawFree

cnc-ddraw pricing →

vkd3d-proton

  • vkd3d-protonFree

vkd3d-proton pricing →

In their own words

cnc-ddraw

cnc-ddraw reimplements DirectDraw to address compatibility problems in older 2D games, including black screens, poor performance, crashes, and faulty Alt+Tab behavior. It can use GDI, OpenGL, or Direct3D 9 rendering, selecting a renderer automatically. Display options include windowed, fullscreen exclusive, and borderless modes; Alt+Enter switches between fullscreen and windowed. GLSL shaders provide upscaling, and other options include an FPS limiter, VSync, mouse sensitivity scaling, and saving and restoring window position, size, and state. The project lists Windows, Linux through Wine, macOS, Android, and virtual machines as supported environments. Setup involves extracting cnc-ddraw.zip into the game folder and starting the game. Wine users must configure the ddraw override in winecfg or run cnc-ddraw config.exe once. The game must use a DirectDraw Software renderer; Direct3D games are not supported. cnc-ddraw is free under the MIT License.

Visit github.com

vkd3d-proton

vkd3d-proton is a translation layer that aims to implement Direct3D 12 on Vulkan and provide Direct3D 12 support development for Proton. It is intended to replace the native Win32 d3d12.dll and d3d12core.dll files in Wine, including Proton, and can also be used on Windows. The project puts performance and game compatibility ahead of support for older drivers and systems, relying on modern Vulkan features. Its README specifies Vulkan 1.3 alongside descriptor indexing, device-feature and extension requirements. RADV is its recommended and most-tested AMD driver, with Mesa 22.0 listed as the minimum; NVIDIA users are advised to use current drivers, with the 535 series as the minimum. Intel GPUs have not been tested by the project. vkd3d-proton does not provide DXGI, sharing that implementation with DXVK 2.1 or later. Its cache for DXBC/DXIL-to-SPIR-V conversion may reduce stutter and loading times. Developer tools include shader dumps and overrides, RenderDoc capture, GPU breadcrumbs and descriptor checks. Native Windows use is mainly described for developer testing.

Visit github.com