Skip to content
SPECIFICTION
Get listed

Fivestars vs Loyalty Gator

Fivestars

fsweb.fivestars.com

Loyalty Gator

loyaltygator.com

Side by side

FigureFivestarsLoyalty Gator
Price from—C$59/mo
Free plan——
Free trial—Yes
Open source——
WebYesYes
iOSYesYes
AndroidYesYes
API—Yes
Plans published23
Spec score · Customer Loyalty Software7.4 (#15)8.3 (#4)
Spec score · Restaurant Marketing Software7.4 (#20)8.3 (#4)
Spec score · Loyalty Program Software7.4 (#27)8.3 (#9)
Founded20112010
HeadquartersSan Francisco, California, United StatesToronto, Ontario, Canada

Plans

Fivestars

  • EssentialsPriced on request
  • ProPriced on request

Fivestars pricing →

Loyalty Gator

  • BiteC$59 a month
  • SnackC$88 a month
  • MealC$179 a month

Loyalty Gator pricing →

In their own words

Fivestars

Fivestars is a paid loyalty and retention platform for local businesses and independent franchises in the United States and Canada. It is available on web, Android, and iOS. The service tracks customer points and rewards, supports tagging and segmentation, and imports contacts from Constant Contact, Mailchimp, and other services. Customers can sign in with a phone number to earn points and redeem rewards. Fivestars Connect runs on a supplied tablet or directly on a point-of-sale system. The dashboard reports new sign-ups, return visits, and rewards redeemed. AutoPilot sends offers for milestones such as a first visit, birthday, or risk of not returning, while promotions can go by text, email, or push notification immediately or on a schedule. The Manager App is included in every package. Essentials lists a customer touchscreen, database, eight AutoPilot campaigns, and one promotion per month. Pro adds unlimited promotions, Text-to-Join, and customer acquisition. Pricing is on request; no numeric plan prices are listed.

Visit fsweb.fivestars.com

Loyalty Gator

Loyalty Gator provides cloud-based customer loyalty, gift card, and employee incentive programs for businesses. Programs can award points for purchases, actions, or referrals, and support digital punch cards and other reward options. The company says businesses do not need a point-of-sale connection. Customers can enroll online and check balances through the business website on a computer, tablet, or smartphone. Businesses can review customer activity and marketing reports and export customer lists for campaigns. The service offers a developer API and Zapier connections, plus integrations including Mailchimp, Shopify, QuickBooks Online, and Square. Its TangoCard connection lets customers redeem points for electronic gift cards. Plans include unlimited loyalty transactions and no transaction fees, subject to fair use and possible extra bandwidth charges. Bite supports up to 100 customers; Snack supports up to 5,000 and adds birthday points and Zapier integration; Meal supports up to 10,000 and adds a customer web portal, referrals, social integration, Google Analytics, and Tawk.to integrations. A 30-day free trial and money-back guarantee are listed, excluding custom development and white-label services. The company says cancellation after the trial requires 30 days' notice.

Visit loyaltygator.com