Optiml vs Tallyfor TaxCalc
Optiml
optiml.caTallyfor TaxCalc
tallyfor.comSide by side
| Figure | Optiml | Tallyfor TaxCalc |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | C$8.25/mo | $1.67/mo |
| Free plan | — | — |
| Free trial | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 3 | 7 |
| Spec score · Tax Planning Software | 7.9 (#7) | 7.6 (#13) |
| Headquarters | Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada | 547 43rd Ave., San Francisco, CA 94121, United States |
| Purpose | Optiml is Canadian retirement planning software that stress-tests financial what-ifs to build a tax-efficient retirement plan. | TaxCalc is Tallyfor’s tax planning module for modeling projections and estimated payments during the year; it does not prepare or file tax returns. |
| Scenario planning | Users can run unlimited what-if scenarios and see how changes affect their financial plan. | Users can compare scenarios side by side, including S-corp elections, Roth conversions, retirement contributions, and charitable timing. |
| Security | Optiml says its services and data are hosted in AWS facilities in central Canada and data in transit is encrypted using 256-bit encryption with TLS/SSL endpoints. | Tallyfor’s terms say its information security program includes encryption of customer personal data at rest and in transit, periodic penetration testing, and access audit logs. |
Plans
Tallyfor TaxCalc
- Additional binders, 1,000 and above$20 a year
- Additional binders, 750–999$24 a year
- Additional binders, 500–749$28 a year
- Additional binders, 300–499$32 a year
- Additional binders, 100–299$36 a year
- Additional binders, 25–99$40 a year
- Base plan$1,000 a year
In their own words
Optiml
Optiml is web-based Canadian retirement planning software that stress-tests financial scenarios to help build a tax-efficient retirement plan. Users can run unlimited what-if scenarios and see how changes affect the plan. Its withdrawal optimizer determines a yearly tax-efficient withdrawal order across RRSP, non-registered, and TFSA accounts, while the CPP and OAS optimizer tests benefit start ages against the user's plan and goal. Success Score tests a plan against up to 50 scenarios, including market downturns, high inflation, and varying returns. The Estate Projector estimates after-tax estate value across the retirement timeline. Eva, an AI assistant, answers questions about the plan, taxes, and strategies using plan context. Optional Wealthica syncing imports account names and balances for supported account types; balances can also be entered manually. Optiml says the sync does not access transaction history or holdings. The company says its services and data are hosted in AWS facilities in central Canada and that data in transit uses 256-bit encryption with TLS/SSL endpoints. It states uptime of 99.9% or higher. Plans include Essentials at C$99 a year, Pro+ at C$249 a year, and Legacy at C$499 a year.
Tallyfor TaxCalc
Tallyfor TaxCalc is web-based tax planning software for CPA firms. It models projections and estimated payments during the year rather than preparing or filing tax returns. The calculator works through federal Form 1040 line by line and state income tax for all 50 states and DC, including multi-state and part-year residency, for tax years through 2026. Users can compare scenarios such as S-corp elections, Roth conversions, retirement contributions and charitable timing. TaxCalc recommends federal and state quarterly payments with safe-harbor logic, tracks payments and flags catch-ups. It produces Excel reports covering tax plans, payment analysis and state returns. Data can come from schedule cards, uploaded prior-year 1040s and W-2s, IRS transcripts and linked K-1s. It connects QuickBooks Online and Xero and exports files to CCH Axcess, Drake, Lacerte, ProConnect and UltraTax. The base plan costs $1,000 a year for 25 binders; a free trial is offered.