Alloy Navigator vs Web Help Desk
Alloy Navigator
alloysoftware.comWeb Help Desk
solarwinds.comSide by side
| Figure | Alloy Navigator | Web Help Desk |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | $19/mo | $26.67/mo |
| Free plan | — | — |
| Free trial | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | — | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Linux | Yes | Yes |
| iOS | Yes | Yes |
| Android | Yes | — |
| API | Yes | — |
| Self-hosted | Yes | Yes |
| Plans published | 3 | 21 |
| Spec score · IT SLA Management Software | 9.3 (#1) | 7.9 (#28) |
| Spec score · IT Help Desk Software | 9.3 (#1) | 7.9 (#34) |
| Spec score · IT Ticketing Systems | 9.3 (#2) | 7.9 (#19) |
| Asset management | Navigator tracks physical and digital assets, maintenance, subscriptions, lifecycle status, warranties, contracts and vendors. | Subscriptions include automated asset discovery, hardware-to-ticket linking, asset lifecycle tracking, and software license management. |
| Deployment | Alloy offers SaaS, on-premises deployment, or installation in a customer Azure or AWS cloud. | Web Help Desk is a self-hosted, on-premises solution that runs in the customer's infrastructure. |
| Integrations | The integrations catalog includes native and REST-API connections such as AWS, Azure, AnyDesk, Apple Calendar, Asana, BambooHR, Confluence, Dell and Dropbox. | It integrates with SolarWinds Network Performance Monitor, Network Configuration Manager, and Server & Application Monitor to surface alerts and create tickets automatically. |
| Security | The pricing page says its data center uses measures including camera monitoring, SSL encryption, and electronic intrusion detection, and offers on-premises hosting for security concerns. | The documentation describes HTTPS, HSTS, and FIPS cryptography support, with HTTPS enabled by default in Web Help Desk 12.7.1 and later and FIPS disabled by default. |
Plans
Alloy Navigator
- Alloy Navigator Explorer$19 a month
- Alloy Navigator Express$49 a month
- Alloy Navigator Enterprise$89 a month
Web Help Desk
- 1–5 technicians$533 a year
- 6–10 technicians$524 a year
- 11–20 technicians$517 a year
- 21–30 technicians$507 a year
- 31–40 technicians$492 a year
- 41–50 technicians$473 a year
- 51–75 technicians$444 a year
- 76–100 technicians$417 a year
- 101–250 technicians$389 a year
- 251–500 technicians$357 a year
In their own words
Alloy Navigator
Alloy Navigator is an IT service management solution for incident, change, and problem workflows, service requests, and IT asset management. It includes ITIL processes and configurable workflow components for business processes. Its customizable self-service portal can be set up without coding and can automate repeat requests. Other listed capabilities include approval workflows, SLA management, a knowledge base, an employee portal, and single sign-on. Organizations can run it on premises, as SaaS, or in their own Azure or AWS cloud. Documented integrations include Microsoft Teams, TeamViewer, Microsoft Entra ID, Dell warranty, Adobe licensing, Intune, and SCCM/MECM; connections can also use a REST API. Native iOS and Android apps serve technicians and users, with a separate inventory scanner app. Plans are billed annually: Explorer costs $19 a month for up to 3 technicians, Express costs $49 a month for 4 or more technicians, and Enterprise costs $89 a month for 4 or more technicians. Each plan allows unlimited requesters. Cloud hosting fees are additional to base product prices.
Web Help Desk
Web Help Desk is a web-based ticketing system for IT support requests from internal and external clients. It can turn incoming email into tickets, route work to technicians or groups, and assign or escalate tickets automatically. Subscriptions include asset discovery, links between hardware and tickets, lifecycle tracking, and software license management. A searchable knowledge base supports end-user FAQs and support articles. Reports and dashboard widgets cover ticket activity, technician performance, customer satisfaction, billing data, and request trends, with configurable SLAs. Integrations with SolarWinds Network Performance Monitor, Network Configuration Manager, and Server & Application Monitor can surface alerts and create tickets. The Dameware Remote Support integration can launch a remote session from a request or asset inventory. Email support includes Gmail and Microsoft 365, and directory integration includes Active Directory and LDAP. Web Help Desk is self-hosted in the customer's infrastructure; supported server systems include specified Windows Server, macOS, and Linux versions. Subscriptions include technical support, product updates, and online customer portal access. There is no free plan, but a full product trial lasts 14 days and does not require a credit card. Annual plans are priced per technician, with unlimited end users: the 1–5 technician tier is $533 a year per technician, and the listed 251–500 tier is $357 a year per technician.