BenManage vs Employee Navigator

BenManage is a web platform for employers administering employee benefits. Its lifecycle coverage includes enrollment, payroll integration, premium remittance, carrier EDI, three-way auditing, employee communications, and ACA reporting. Employees can enroll through digital self-service, live call center support, or on-site enrollment. The FAQ lists payroll connections for ADP, Paylocity, Paychex, Paycor, UKG, Viventium, iSolved, and Proliant, and says a custom connection can be built for other providers. BenManage says it has more than 150 pre-built and pre-approved carrier connections. Voluntary premiums go to carriers only when employees receive paychecks, and the FAQ says employers do not receive a voluntary carrier bill. Continuous auditing compares payroll deductions, remitted amounts, and carrier records to identify discrepancies. The service says every call is recorded and retained indefinitely, with AI-powered analysis for quality assurance and insights. Its no-cost plan provides benefits administration lifecycle services and technology on an à la carte basis. BenManage says standard implementations take 7–15 business days from kickoff to go-live.

Employee Navigator is a benefits administration, HR, and compliance platform for insurance brokers, employers, and integrated partners. Employees can enroll themselves, compare and select medical, dental, vision, life, HSA, HRA, FSA, LPFSA, DCA, and commuter plans, review coverage, see benefit details, and monitor enrollment deadlines. HR functions include onboarding, ACA reporting, payroll integrations, HR management, time-off tracking, eligibility rules, payroll deductions, and COBRA administration. Onboarding supports custom task lists, new-hire forms, policy-acknowledgement tracking, and an audit trail. Employees can use Android and iOS apps or the web to enroll, view compliance documents, request or review PTO, access contacts, and see benefits. Employee Navigator lists connections with more than 600 partners and integration with 83 payroll partners. It says annual audits cover SOC 2 Type II, HITRUST, NIST, GDPR, 23 NYCRR 500, and CCPA. Two-factor authentication is required. Pricing is on request, with no free plan.