Clear I-9 vs EMP Trust Electronic Form I-9

Clear I-9 is standalone web software for managing Form I-9 compliance. Step-by-step guidance and automated checks support form completion, while time-stamped, version-controlled records and centralized dashboards support review and audit work. Section 2 can be handled remotely through live video verification or approved U.S.-based representatives. The product also supports E-Verify case management, including automatic data transfer, alerts, and follow-up workflows for Tentative Nonconfirmations. HRlogics describes the software for distributed teams and high-volume hiring in staffing, education, construction, hospitality, event venues, and healthcare. Teams can manage multiple locations with role-based access and customizable dashboards. Integration options include pre-built connections, public API access, CSV imports, and secure file transfers; named providers include ADP, Gusto, UKG, Paychex, and Paycom. The product page describes encrypted storage, access controls, automated versioning, and SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type II certification. It is mobile-friendly and responsive, and HRlogics says U.S.-based human support, onboarding, and training tools are included. Pricing is not published; the page invites visitors to schedule a demo.

EMP Trust Electronic Form I-9 helps employers capture, prepare, electronically sign, store, and audit Form I-9 records. Real-time field checks, guidance, and alerts flag missing or incorrect information. For remote hiring, employees can complete Section 1 on a mobile-friendly system, while authorized representatives or EMPTrust’s remote verification network can complete Section 2. The service supports E-Verify submissions, automated case creation, responses, and status tracking; EMPTrust describes itself as a certified E-Verify Employer Agent. HR systems can connect through web services, batch file automation, uploads, and API integrations with HRIS and payroll providers. Signature choices include wet, digital, and third-party tools. Compliance dashboards, audit reports, and digital trails support review, and migration, digitization, audit, and remediation services address legacy I-9 records. The product is offered as SaaS or for installation on a corporate network. EMPTrust states that the service is SOC 2 Type II compliant and uses AES-256 encryption at rest and in transit, with role-based access controls. It lists 24/7 support. Pricing is on request, and a free plan is not available.