HotCRP vs Smart Abstract
HotCRP
hotcrp.comSmart Abstract
smart-abstract.comSide by side
| Figure | HotCRP | Smart Abstract |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | Free | — |
| Free plan | Yes | — |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Open source | Yes | — |
| Web | Yes | Yes |
| macOS | Yes | — |
| Linux | Yes | — |
| API | Yes | — |
| Self-hosted | Yes | — |
| Plans published | 11 | 0 |
| Spec score · Call for Papers Software | 9.1 (#2) | 6.9 (#22) |
| Purpose | HotCRP manages the conference review process, including paper submissions and reviews. | Smart Abstract manages a scientific conference workflow from abstract submission and review through session planning and creation of the book of abstracts. |
| Review | Review features include customizable forms, LaTeX math, multiple rounds, offline reviewing, delegation, and external reviewer invitations. | Review forms can use more than 25 grading scales, yes/no questions, and recommendations, and abstracts can be assigned to reviewers automatically. |
| Support | Support for independent conference sites is limited to bug fixes, and classroom use has no support. | The service team advises customers during initial setup and configures the conference app initially with the customer's design. |
Plans
HotCRP
- ACM-sponsoredFree
- ACM-sponsoredFree
- ClassroomFree
- ClassroomFree
- Free test siteFree
- Free test siteFree
- USENIX-sponsoredFree
- USENIX-sponsoredFree
- Independent$7.50, paid once
- Independent$7.50, paid once
In their own words
HotCRP
HotCRP manages conference paper submissions and reviews, either as open-source software for self-hosting or through the hosted HotCRP.com service. Submission tools include customizable forms, optional registration, program-committee conflict collection, and configurable PDF checks. Papers can be assigned by hand, in batches, or automatically, including through globally optimal assignments. Search, sorting, bulk downloads, formulas, and tags help organize submissions. Review workflows support custom forms, LaTeX math, multiple rounds, offline reviewing, delegation, and external reviewers. Program committee meeting tools include rebuttals, votes, rankings, a live tracker, decision types, and mailing users. The REST API uses bearer tokens that can be scoped, including for read-only access or selected papers. HotCRP.com connects with ACM publication services for copyright forms, final versions, PDF checks, proceedings, and Digital Library export. Self-hosting requires a web server and software including Nginx, PHP 7.3 or higher, MariaDB, and PHP packages. Listed free plans serve certain sponsored events and classroom use; independent conferences pay $7.50 per submission after the deadline.
Smart Abstract
Smart Abstract is a web-based system for scientific conference workflows, covering abstract submission, review, programme planning and publication. It serves associations, professional congress organizers, and research and education organizations running conferences or annual meetings. Review forms can combine more than 25 grading scales with yes/no questions and recommendations, while submissions can be assigned to reviewers automatically. The optional Review PLUS add-on adds multi-stage reviews, custom questionnaires and asynchronous author–reviewer comments. A visual planner arranges sessions by room and time with drag-and-drop scheduling, flags conflicts such as a speaker booked twice, and exports schedules to Word or Excel. The system sends confirmations, reminders and acceptance notices with session information, and can prepare a Word book of abstracts for publisher publication interfaces. Its conference app presents programmes, agendas, abstracts, floor plans, exhibitors and announcements, with archives available up to 12 months. Hybrid add-ons include livestreams, meetings, on-demand media, Q&A, polls and networking. Pricing is on request.